unflinching idealism ... since 1997 archivessitemapabouthelpfeedback
all are welcome to read, write and think
  • Home
  • InFocus
  • Themes
  • Columns
  • Articles
  • Fiction
  • iLogs
  • Gallery
  • Unplugged
  • Writers
  • Interactors
  • Tags
Sign in | Join Chowk
web chowk
  • Article
  • Interact
  • read writer comments
  • add to favorites
  • get rss feeds
  • print
  • email this link

India’s Foreign Policy: An Analysis

Aparna Pande January 15, 2007

Latest comments   flat   threaded   latest   oldest   all
listing 1-16   1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11

#279 Posted by friend on January 22, 2007 5:41:17 pm
Ijaz,
Wonderful photographs. I also did some climbing and hiking in Ladakh, Kashmir, UP and Nepal Himalayas. I will try to find and share some of my photographs of Yamuna basin.
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#278 Posted by tahmed32 on January 22, 2007 9:25:25 am
ijaz gul: That is truly fascinating - i.e. to have caves with paintings from neolithic/paleolothic times in baluchistan. If you are able to post pictures of these caves, that would be truly a first I think. Since I dont recall ever seeing such pictures anywhere. The cave paintings in france provided a rich source of info on the kind of animal life in europe in the last 40,000 years or so, and these pictures would no doubt tell a lot about what baluchistan was like back then (in the middle of the desert in Sahara, there are caves with pictures of zebras and other animals no one thought ever lived there).

Your pictures of the sarasvati river bed bring to life what most of us have only heard read about - i.e. the ancient sarasvati river that I understand is referred to in the rig vedas and which probably dried out near the end of the indus valley civilization. It seems likely that these ancient river was around in neolithic times (prior to 6000 BC) as well when there were these pre-indus valley civilization settlements.
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#277 Posted by ijaz_gul on January 22, 2007 7:10:27 am
1. The first photo is a brackish water (bitter, total dissolved solids >60,000ppm). These in local language are called TARAIS, where cattle can graze but not drink. It is the old bed of River Nara (Srasvati). These dhands dot the entire lndscape along the obscured river bed. This is where I met Raheela. She was approaching from the direction of Umerkot, while a team of Geo in Pajeros was filming her approach. While she moved from South West to North East, I was moving East right upto the Indo-Pak border.
2. This is called the Nara Ridge/faultline. It was basically the study of this fault line that enabled me to be very current on the earthquacke in 2005. These ridges look like pyramids but are actually the folds of the ground. It was probably this tectonic movement and tsunamis that got trapped inland, that the river vanished and salt water lakes were formed. One theory has it that the river changed its course and became Yummna that now flows in India. This photo is taken near Dij Kot.
3. These are those golden sand dunes towering upto 500`. Legend has it that in severe summers though I experienced temperatures upto 52C, they become dry quicksand in which even camels drown. These dunes move a few feet per year. The bowl you see is the hard ground where deer come to sip mosture. We dug a few feet and water began to slowly seep very slowly. Water quality <100ppm. The lonely shadow is mine.
4. These are the granite hills of Nagarparker. Note the two different colors of the ridges. The one that is in the fore ground has clear signs that water once flowed from left to right. This is where Nara river debouched into the Arabian sea.

Thanx for helping out.
Cheerios
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#276 Posted by zeemax on January 22, 2007 4:48:20 am
Here ...






Ijaz, appreciate commentary on each. These are simply beutiful.
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#275 Posted by ijaz_gul on January 21, 2007 9:51:12 pm
I traversed thoe cavs in 1992. Sorry np photos but will try to get them. They had paintings of animals and hands like the ones we find in France.These pics are from NARA.
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#274 Posted by tahmed32 on January 21, 2007 9:29:03 pm
ijazgul: I checked out the pictures. They do show up (did not require a Yahoo ID). I dont see any caves there though. If you have any of those pictures available, those would be great to see. Since you visited those caves - what kind of things do they have their to indicate human habitation? (like do they have human skeletons only, or artifacts and cave paintings and signs of cooking spots as well as middens (garbage dumps, which often yield a lot of information as well).
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#273 Posted by ijaz_gul on January 21, 2007 8:36:47 pm
Here it is.
http://pg.photos.yahoo.com/ph/ijaz_gul/album?.dir=9c97scd&.src=ph&store=&prodid=&.done=http%3a//photos.yahoo.com/ph//my_photos
Hope this works, but I think you need a Yahoo ID.
Cheerios
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#272 Posted by tahmed32 on January 21, 2007 2:43:27 pm
ijaz: you can also provide a link to the place by cutting and pasting the http address in your post. that is much simpler. that way we can all see these pictures you refer to in #269
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#271 Posted by zeemax on January 21, 2007 1:38:24 pm
#269 by ijaz_gul

Pls post your yahoo photo album address. Thanks.
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#270 Posted by arjun2 on January 21, 2007 11:37:05 am

#269 by ijaz_gul on January 21, 2007 11:22am PT

Yahoo photos won`t let you link directly to their images. Use photobucket.
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#269 Posted by ijaz_gul on January 21, 2007 11:22:47 am
This is the bitter lake where I met Raheela. This is a brackish Oasis, and the old bed of Nara (Sarasvati)River. In local anguage it is called TARAI.


These are the pyramids near Dij Kot. The are the actual Nara Fault or the ridge.


The different shades og granite clearly show the old flow of the Nara river near Nagar Parkar.


This is the typical desert. The lonely shadow is mine.
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#268 Posted by tahmed32 on January 21, 2007 8:57:50 am
ijazgul #257 Thanks for your providing the directions to these cro-magnon sites in baluchistan. Definitely off the beaten path. I shall print out your post and save the directions in the hope that one day I will get the chance to see these places for myself. These are I assume from the the neolothic times (pre-6000) or perhaps even earlier (before 10,000 BC). In either case, they would be well before even the indus valley civilization. Do they have any artifacts, wall paintings?

The longest trek I ever did was just a one day thing over 20 miles or so - going up Mount Miranjani then following the pipeline to muree. That is nothing compared to what you have been doing, and iI assume you have done that. but if you havent tried out that route I highly recommend it - great scenery along the path, and no motorized traffic possible of course.


On posting pictures:
1. bring cursor over picture you wish to post, right click mouse and select (with left click) ``picture location`` or ``properties`` from the menu that appears. You will see the ``http:...`` thing there that you copy.

2. Come to chowk page where you type your message (``Your comments``) and type in

(img src = ``http:....``)

That is all. Important: I used ( and ) above. You should use < and > instead. I did not use < or > since that would not post properly as the computer system would assume i am posting a picture!!

On last thing: how about posting some pictures of these caves if you took them? Chowk has the option to post pictures that stay for a long time on the front page.
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#267 Posted by subhashjoshi on January 20, 2007 11:33:15 pm
Re: # 248 Arjun

And just imagine some of the steel for these trucks/buses might come from those recycled railroad tracks....Aw shit!!!

reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#266 Posted by subhashjoshi on January 20, 2007 11:29:12 pm
I think civilization is when people do NOT shit by the railroad tracks, and by that measure India is definitely NOT a civilization today. But it was a civilization in those ANCIENT times when there were no railroad tracks. Case solved for India. Now Pakis decide about Pakistan.

reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#265 Posted by subhashjoshi on January 20, 2007 11:24:49 pm
Re: # 264 NangaPir

Wow! Hilarious!

reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#264 Posted by NangaPir on January 20, 2007 11:01:08 pm
TALIBANS EXECUTE HIJACKERS


A summary court is in session in Khendar. Here are the initial breakthrough
findings. You are the judge.
Prime suspect Mujahid Gul Khan`s Statement:

`Twas the night before the Christmas , and God it was neat
The neighbors were both gone, and Sita was in heat
The doors were all boIted, and the phone off the hook
It was time for some nooky, by hook or by crook.
*****************************************************
Sita in her teddy, and I in the nude
Had just hit the bedroom and reached for the lube
When out in the city there arose such a cry,
That I lost my boner and poor Sita went dry.
*****************************************************
Up to the window I sprang like an elf,
Tore back the shade while she played with herself.
The Shiva on the crest of the boulder we`d built,
Showed a broom up his ass, clean up to the hilt.
*****************************************************
When what to my wondering eye should appears,
But a rusty old airplane and five mangy hijackers.
With a fat little pilot, half out of his dhoti
A sock in his ear and a bra on his petuti.
*****************************************************
Sure as I`m speaking, the plane was as high as a kite.
And chief hijacker yelled to pilot, but it didn`t sound right.
Whoa Shithead, whoa Asshole, whoa Stupid, whoa Putz,
Either slow down your father or I`ll cut off your nuts.
*****************************************************
Look out for the airport, and don`t hit the tree,
Quit shaking the plane, `cause I gotta go pee,
They cleared the airport, the tree got a rub,
Just as Gul Khan leaned out and threw up on his shrub.
*****************************************************
(SCENE REPORTED AT AMRITSER AIRPORT, INDIA)
And then from the roof we heard such a clatter,
As each little hijacker now emptied his bladder.
Vajpayee was donnig his jacket to cover his ass,
When down the sky airplane came with a crash.
*****************************************************
(ACCOUNT OF JASWANT SINGH AT KHENDAR)
His suit was all smelly with perfume galore,
He looked like a bum and smelled like a whore.
“That was some brothel,`` he said with a smile,
``The Indians are pooped, and I`ll just stay here awhile``.
*****************************************************
(RELEASED ONE PASSANGER DESCRIBED HIJACKER KHAN GUL AS)
He walked to the kitchen, himself poured a drink,
Then whipped out his pecker and pissed in the sink.
I started to laugh my wife smiled with glee,
The old boy hung nearly down to his knee.
*****************************************************
(TALIBANS THROUGHLY SEARCHED INDIAN PLANE AND FOUND)
Back in the den, Talibans reached in the sacks,
But documents were all gone, and some new things were packed.
The first thing they found was a pair of false tits,
The next was a handgun with a penis that spits.
*****************************************************
(HONEYMOONERS WERE ON PLANE)
A box filled with condoms was the next find,
And a six pair of Panties, the Brahmin kind.
A bra without nipples, a penis extension,
And several other things, that I shouldn`t even mention.
*****************************************************
A cock ring, a G-string, all types of oil,
A dildo so long, it lay in a coil.
``This surf ain`t for passengers, world will shit,
So we`ll leave `em here and then we`ll just split.``
********************************************************************
(PLANE LEAVES FOR INDIA - FINAL MOMENTS)
Indians filled every stocking and then took their leaves,
With one tiny butt plug tucked under their sleeves.
Jaswant sprang to his sleigh, but his feet were like lead,
Thus he fell on his ass and broke wind instead.
*****************************************************
In time he was seated and took the reins of his hitch,
Saying, ``Take me home pilot, this night`s been a bitch!``
The night was near gone when we heard a Mujahid shout,
``The best thing about Jihad is that it never wears out``
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#263 Posted by mohar11 on January 20, 2007 6:36:08 pm
Re: # 262

Some of the Best products of human civilization have been patently ugly, unkempt and eccentric... einstein, gandhi, newton, socretes, shaw... scientists, philosophers, the do-gooders...

And on the otherhand - the evil that human civilization ever produced have always been very well-dressed and manicured: hitler, stalin, pinochet, saddam, jinnah...

It`s a no contest... if human civilization depended on individuals with good robes and clean fingernails for its survival, we all would have been long extinct by now... human civilization is built on ideas and innovations, and unfortunately, people with ideas and innovations do not always bother to dress well and clean their finger-nails...

:)
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#262 Posted by bbabu on January 20, 2007 2:53:39 pm
Re: # 244

I do think dressing well and not smelling bad is a sign of civilization. That is not the only sign of a civilization.
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#261 Posted by KaalChakra on January 20, 2007 1:53:40 pm
``when history is written, the british time in south asia will be of little consequence.....``

Don`t know about SA, but in the future history of India, the British time is more likely to be seen as a brief but fundamentally important discontinuity. Of course, only Time will tell how consequential this period may ultimately be...

(Sorry, not getting into ``what is or is not India, or whether my backyard is a full civilization more than my living room`` debates :):))
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#260 Posted by bbabu on January 20, 2007 1:35:33 pm
Re: # 259

you are the same dude who thinks mullahs and the Taliban have a popular base without their ISI masters.


At Border, Signs of Pakistani Role in Taliban Surge
By CARLOTTA GALL
QUETTA, Pakistan — The most explosive question about the Taliban resurgence here along the border between Afghanistan and Pakistan is this: Have Pakistani intelligence agencies been promoting the Islamic insurgency?

The government of Pakistan vehemently rejects the allegation and insists that it is fully committed to help American and NATO forces prevail against the Taliban militants who were driven from power in Afghanistan in 2001.

Western diplomats in both countries and Pakistani opposition figures say that Pakistani intelligence agencies — in particular the powerful Inter-Services Intelligence and Military Intelligence — have been supporting a Taliban restoration, motivated not only by Islamic fervor but also by a longstanding view that the jihadist movement allows them to assert greater influence on Pakistan’s vulnerable western flank.

More than two weeks of reporting along this frontier, including dozens of interviews with residents on each side of the porous border, leaves little doubt that Quetta is an important base for the Taliban, and found many signs that Pakistani authorities are encouraging the insurgents, if not sponsoring them.

The evidence is provided in fearful whispers, and it is anecdotal.

At Jamiya Islamiya, a religious school here in Quetta, Taliban sympathies are on flagrant display, and residents say students have gone with their teachers’ blessings to die in suicide bombings in Afghanistan.

Three families whose sons had died as suicide bombers in Afghanistan said they were afraid to talk about the deaths because of pressure from Pakistani intelligence agents. Local people say dozens of families have lost sons in Afghanistan as suicide bombers and fighters.

One former Taliban commander said in an interview that he had been jailed by Pakistani intelligence officials because he would not go to Afghanistan to fight. He said that, for Western and local consumption, his arrest had been billed as part of Pakistan’s crackdown on the Taliban in Pakistan. Former Taliban members who have refused to fight in Afghanistan have been arrested — or even mysteriously killed — after resisting pressure to re-enlist in the Taliban, Pakistani and Afghan tribal elders said.

“The Pakistanis are actively supporting the Taliban,” declared a Western diplomat in an interview in Kabul. He said he had seen an intelligence report of a recent meeting on the Afghan border between a senior Taliban commander and a retired colonel of the Pakistani Inter-Services Intelligence.

Pakistanis and Afghans interviewed on the frontier, frightened by the long reach of Pakistan’s intelligence agencies, spoke only with assurances that they would not be named. Even then, they spoke cautiously.

The Pakistani military and intelligence services have for decades used religious parties as a convenient instrument to keep domestic political opponents at bay and for foreign policy adventures, said Husain Haqqani, a former adviser to several of Pakistan’s prime ministers and the author of a book on the relationship between the Islamists and the Pakistani security forces.

The religious parties recruited for the jihad in Kashmir and Afghanistan from the 1980s, when the Pakistani intelligence agencies ran the resistance by the mujahedeen and channeled money to them from the United States and Saudi Arabia to fight the Soviet Union in Afghanistan, Mr. Haqqani said.

In return for help in Kashmir and Afghanistan the intelligence services would rig votes for the religious parties and allow them freedom to operate, he said.

“The religious parties provide them with recruits, personnel, cover and deniability,” Mr. Haqqani said in a telephone interview from Washington, where he is now a visiting scholar at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace.

The Inter-Services Intelligence once had an entire wing dedicated to training jihadis, he said. Today the religious parties probably have enough of their own people to do the training, but, he added, the I.S.I. so thoroughly monitors phone calls and people’s movements that it would be almost impossible for any religious party to operate a training camp without its knowledge.

“They trained the people who are at the heart of it all, and they have done nothing to roll back their protégés,” Mr. Haqqani said.

After the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks in the United States, President Pervez Musharraf, under strong American pressure, pledged to help root out Islamic extremism, and, as both head of the army and president, he has more direct control of the intelligence services than past civilian prime ministers. But according to several analysts, Pakistani intelligence officials believe it is more prudent to prepare for the day when Western troops leave Afghanistan.

Pakistan has long seen jihadi movements like the Taliban as a counter to Indian and Russian influence next door in Afghanistan, the Western diplomat and other analysts said, and as a way to provide Pakistan with “strategic depth,” or a friendly buffer on its western border.

In Pashtunabad, a warren of high mud-brick walls and narrow lanes in Quetta, the links of the government, religious parties and Taliban commanders to a local madrasa are thinly hidden, said a local opposition party member who lives in the neighborhood.

Three students from the madrasa went to Afghanistan recently on suicide missions, he said. The family of one of the men admitted that he had blown himself up but denied that he had attended the school. The man’s brother suggested that he had been forced into the mission and that someone had recruited him for payment.

“Nowadays people are getting money from somewhere and they are killing other people’s children,” he said. “We are afraid of this government,” he said. His father said he feared the same people would try to take his other son and asked that no family names be used.

President Musharraf relies on the religious party Jamiat Ulema-i-Islam, or J.U.I., which dominates this province, Baluchistan, as an important partner in the provincial and national parliaments.

At a madrasa, called simply Jamiya Islamiya, on winding Hajji Ghabi Road, a board in the courtyard proudly declares “Long Live Mullah Omar,” in praise of the Taliban leader, and “Long Live Fazlur Rehman,” the leader of J.U.I.

Members of the provincial government and Jamiat Ulema-i-Islam are frequent visitors to the school, the local opposition party member said, asking that his name not be used because he feared Pakistan’s intelligence services. People on motorbikes with green government license plates visit at night, he said, as do luxurious sport utility vehicles with blackened windows, a favorite of Taliban commanders.

Maulvi Noor Muhammad, a Jamiat Ulema-i-Islam representative from Baluchistan in the National Assembly, recently received a guest barefoot while sitting on the floor of a grubby district office in Quetta, a map of the world above him painted on the wall to represent his belief in worldwide Islamic revolution.

He denied providing the militants any logistical support. “The J.U.I. is not supporting the Taliban anymore,” he said. “We are only providing moral support. We pray for their success in ousting the foreign troops from the land of Afghanistan.”

On a recent morning, the deputy director of the Jamiya Islamiya madrasa, Qari Muhammad Ibrahim, declined to meet a female reporter for The New York Times but answered a question from a local male reporter.

He did not deny that some of the madrasa’s 280 students had gone to fight in Afghanistan. “In the Koran it is written that it is every Muslim’s right to fight jihad,” he said. “All we are telling them is what is in the Koran, and then it’s up to them to go to jihad.”

NATO officials and Western diplomats in Afghanistan have grown increasingly critical of Pakistan for allowing the Taliban leaders, commanders and soldiers to operate from their country, which has given an advantage to the insurgency in southern Afghanistan. In September, Gen. James L. Jones, then NATO’s supreme commander, told the Senate Foreign Relations Committee that Quetta remained the headquarters of the Taliban movement.

Still, Pakistan has insisted that the Taliban leadership is not based in Quetta. “If there are Taliban in Quetta, they are few,” said Pakistan’s minister for information and broadcasting, Tariq Azim Khan. “You can count them on your fingers.”

American officials and Western diplomats noted that, when put under enough pressure, Pakistan had come through with flashes of cooperation. But that only seems to reinforce the view that Pakistan’s intelligence agencies are more in touch with what is going on in the Taliban insurgency than the government lets on publicly.

For instance, a senior Taliban leader, Mullah Akhtar Muhammad Osmani, who operated on both sides of the border, was killed in an airstrike in Afghanistan on Dec. 19, after Pakistan helped track him, an American official in Afghanistan said.

At the same time, a kind of dirty war is building between Afghan and Pakistani intelligence agencies. A senior Afghan intelligence official said one of its informers in Pakistan was recently killed and dumped in pieces in Peshawar, a border town. The Afghan intelligence service has also recently arrested two Afghan generals, one retired, who have been charged with spying for Pakistan, as well as a Pakistani suspected of being an intelligence agent.

President Musharraf has acknowledged that some retired Pakistani intelligence officials may still be involved in supporting their former protégés in the Taliban.

Hamid Gul, the former director general of Pakistani intelligence, remains a public and unapologetic supporter of the Taliban, visiting madrasas and speaking in support of jihad at graduation ceremonies.

Afghan intelligence officials recently produced a captured insurgent who said Mr. Gul facilitated his training and logistics through an office in the Pakistani town of Nowshera, in the North-West Frontier Province, west of the capital, Islamabad.

NATO and American officials in Afghanistan say there is also evidence of support from current midlevel Pakistani intelligence officials. Just how far up that support reaches remains in dispute.

At least five villages in Pishin, a district northwest of Quetta that stretches toward the Afghan border, lost sons in the recent fighting in Kandahar between the Taliban and NATO forces, opposition politicians said.

One village, Karbala, is a main center of support for the jihad, local people say. Unlike the other villages, which blend into the stark desertlike landscape with their mud-brick houses and compound walls, Karbala has lavish houses, mosques and madrasas, suggesting an unusual wealth.

Farther on, in the village of Bagarzai, lies the grave of Azizullah, a religious scholar who used only one name and acquired fame as a Taliban commander.

Only 25, he was killed with a group of 15 to 20 men in an airstrike in the Afghan province of Helmand on May 22, said his father, Hajji Abdul Hai. Thousands of people attended his funeral, including senior members of the provincial government, the father said.

Mr. Hai, 50, who is a Jamiat Ulema-i-Islam member, denied that his son had been persuaded to fight by anyone. “From the start it was his spirit to take part in jihad,” his father said. “It’s all to do with personal will. If someone agrees, then he goes. Even if someone wishes to, no one can stop him.”

It is an argument that supporters of the jihad use frequently. But for some of the families mourning their sons, there is no doubt that the madrasas and the religious parties are the first point of contact.

That was the conclusion reached by the family of Muhammad Daoud, a 22-year-old man from Pishih who disappeared more than a year ago.

“In our search we went to many places and everyone said different things,” said his father, Hajji Noora Gul. “We went to the madrasa in Pashtunabad, but no one was ready to tell us his whereabouts.”

“Even the madrasa people did not know,” he added. “Behind the curtain of the madrasa, maybe there are other people who do this. Maybe there are some businessmen who take them.”

Then, he said, a Taliban propaganda CD came out showing his son with a group of others taking an oath before the Taliban commander, Mullah Dadullah.

“He had a shawl over his head and was preparing for a suicide bombing,” Mr. Gul said. “He said, ‘I am fighting for God, and I am ready for this.’ ”

His eldest son, Alla Dad, 33, blamed the jihadi groups and the Inter-Services Intelligence. “We don’t know how he made contact with those jihadi groups,” he said. “There are some groups active in taking people to Afghanistan and they are active in Quetta.

“All Taliban are I.S.I. Taliban,” he added. “It is not possible to go to Afghanistan without the help of the I.S.I. Everyone says this.”

David Rohde contributed reporting from Kabul, Afghanistan.


reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#259 Posted by bulleya on January 20, 2007 1:21:56 pm
....the best book i have read on south asian history, or of an era in that history is, ``The White Mughals,`` by Dalrymple.....it is a classic and a must read for anyone who wants knowledge about the British era of the Sub-Continent, based on very very detailed research.....

....i had always wondered about the social changes that were taking place in the Sub-Continent during the British days....it couldn`t have been as simple as East is East and West is West or the White Man`s Burden.....

....South Asia was one of the most developed and richest areas in the world....it was not a backwaters conquered by the White man.....it had industry, created art, poetry, architecture etc.......

...it is said that, in retrospect, when history is written, the british time in south asia will be of little consequence.....a brief 200 year blimp....however it was instrumental in creating three or four countries - two out of which, i.e. India and Pakistan are completely artificial and would not have come into existence had the british not arrived......

.........it is interesting to read about the way the mughal empire had totally disintegrated and local powers were declaring their indepenendence.....these local powers would have formed their own countries.....hyderabad, marathas, mysore, punjab, etc......much of pakistan was actually afghanistan and would have been afghanisan today had young british soldiers not conquered these regions......

.........however, the most interesting part is the merging of britishers and locals....contrary to popular belief by the late 18th century, british had started heavy intermarraiges with the locals and were well on their way to merging into the local population, like the previous rulers of south asia........i dont` remember the exact figure, but 1/3rd (?) of the britishers had local wives.......they wore local clothes and spent their whole lives in south asia, barely ever returning to england.......

........it was only in the late part of the 18th century, 1780 or so, that the british stopped this integration....the british viceroy/governor general passed a law that children who were a product of the joint white-local marriages would not be considered full british subjects...they would not be sent to england for education.....they could only join british military and civil services at low posts etc......this was to discourage the intermingling of races....

....cornwallis - the governor general - had been defeated by the americans in the revolutionary war, before being assigned to india........i assume he saw a new, ``race`` emerge in america - a combination of english marrying with others - which considered itself different from its originating english race.....perhaps he feared the same thing happening in south asia.......thereby bringing in the above laws......

it is, thus, only after the late 18th century that the separation of whites and locals really began.....this is when kipling`s east is east, west is west, never the twain shall meet, became the norm.....perhaps kipling himself did not know the history of the area he was living, where east and west were quite close to meeting, infact had met already, prior to his days......
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#258 Posted by jang on January 20, 2007 12:15:44 pm
#244 muslim edge in civilization is being hotly debated on the ``in case of a wife being lewd`` thread.

#247 the 6-th chinese travellers to india marvelled at the fact that indian pupulance had at least one bath a day and wore fresh linen clothes as opposed to rags and skins that other populations he knew of.
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#257 Posted by ijaz_gul on January 20, 2007 11:16:01 am
Tahmed32,
There is no meaness about it nor any intent to take away credit from where it is due. Extreme sports is an area where there are no umpires or referees and the words of the person of the momment are taken as truth. She herself acknowledged that she had not moved ito the heart. I was just putting the record straight.

As humans, once we identify a high performer, we tend to overlook other shortcomings and glorify. I am just mentioning a fact to which I am a witness. I`ll just qoute two examples.

A friend Peerzada is a Pride of Performance inr mountaineering. He with a team of two other Pakistanis in poor visibility thought they scaled Nanga Parbat. Unlike the other two, Peerzada had doubts whether he had reached the actual summit or was it just an adjacent pinnacle a few meters below. Peerzada does not claim he scaled the peak.

Reinhold Messner lost his brother during descent from Nanga Parbat. People commented that because his brother had scaled the peak before him, he allowed him to wander off in the blizzard so that he alone could claim the summit. Messner maintained that he had occompanied his brother a considerable distance. Now after 25 years, he has recovered his brothers body to vindicate himself. Such is the character that makes extreme sports.

If I never felt for Raheela the way I did, I would never have written about her.

As for Dera Bugti, you get there via Kashmore. From there you go to Patthar Nullah and then onto the caves. Unless who have a heavey contigent of security, movement is dangerous. Another way to get to the caves is to travel by the track running from Dera Bughti to Pirkoh. Halfway, you abandon it for the route going to Kolhu. Enroute you will see a series of flattened type entrances. These are the caves. For Dhanasar, you move to Zhob from Quetta. Short of Zhob, you turn right along the Sulaiman range into the Neli Kach. Thats where you will find the caves.

By the way, how do we paste pics?
Cheerios

reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#256 Posted by zeemax on January 20, 2007 10:37:13 am
#255 by tahmed32

Yes her family was from Lahore. Thanks for posting her pics which are from her website which, interestingly, is now a matrimonial site.

I first came to know about her when guides in Hunza told me about her in 2000. This was after she had completed a two week trek from Gilgit to the base camp of K-2 through Fairy Meadows. The guide told me it was unbelievable how she wanted to keep on going when everyone else was collapsing ... including that guide who was sturdier than a horse.

Well .. R.I.P.
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#255 Posted by tahmed32 on January 20, 2007 10:22:41 am
zeemax #240 Thanks for posting. She was actually a Norwegian citizen, but of Pakistani origin. And is now buried in Lahore. After having trekked around the world, from the arctic to across the sahara and also the amazon and of course within Pakistan. Here are a couple of more pictures of her I dug out of the internet.

I hope ijaz gul posts some more on his wanderings in baluchistan.



reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#254 Posted by zeemax on January 20, 2007 10:00:16 am
#253 by mohar11

Yeah. She was a Norwegian citizen but spent most of her time trekking in impossible terrain in Pakistan.
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#253 Posted by mohar11 on January 20, 2007 9:55:05 am
Re: # 252

Damn... :(
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#252 Posted by zeemax on January 20, 2007 9:29:50 am
#251 by mohar11

She was in Islamabad in Margalla Towers on the 10th floor on the 8th October 2005 ...
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#251 Posted by mohar11 on January 20, 2007 9:20:56 am
Re: # 250

What happened - how did she die?
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#250 Posted by zeemax on January 20, 2007 9:17:49 am
#242 by tahmed32

In memorium of that remarkable woman, who died due to the whimsical upheavals of the same Nature that she so loved to explore ...

reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#249 Posted by mohar11 on January 20, 2007 9:15:05 am
Re: # 248

That means - not only hamidm`s medicines are made by the hated heeng-eaters, the food he eats would be transported by trucks made by the heeng-eaters...

Hmmm... now what is he going to do...:)
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#248 Posted by arjun2 on January 20, 2007 9:05:48 am
Indians will teach Pakis how to assemble trucks...

India’s TATA Motors infiltrates Pakistan

NEW DELHI: India’s largest automobile firm TATA Motors has infiltrated Pakistan, according to a press release issued by the company on Friday.

The company said that its South Korean venture TATA Daewoo Commercial Vehicle Corporation (TDCVC) had set up a truck and bus assembling unit in Karachi. It said that it had entered into a technical assistance pact with Afzal Motors (Pvt) Ltd of Pakistan to assemble trucks and buses. The plant has a capacity to produce 3,000 vehicles a year and would assemble heavy-duty trucks and buses. TDCV, which is a 100 percent subsidiary of TATA Motors, is the second largest manufacturer of heavy-duty trucks in South Korea, with a modern manufacturing facility at Gunsan. It is also the largest exporter of heavy-duty trucks from South Korea, accounting for about two-thirds of the export of such vehicles from the country. In 2005-06, TDCV posted a turnover of Rs 15,840 million, a growth of 34.5 percent, and a profit of Rs 580 million, a growth of 160 percent. iftikhar gilani
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#247 Posted by dost_mittar on January 20, 2007 9:04:54 am
247:
....and oh, don`t forget that you can see communal baths at Mahenjo daro, along with efficient sewerage system. Our ancestors lost their way somewhere along the line.
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#246 Posted by dost_mittar on January 20, 2007 8:48:03 am
hamidm:

If bath is the first step towards civilisation, our ancestors took that step a long time ago. A bath for hindus first thing in the morning was/is obligatory for practising sikhs and hindus before doing their ritual pooja/paath. Temples in India had a pool so people would take a dip (kind of wazoo, if you will) before their pooja; you have probably seen in pictures the large pool outside the Golden Temple.

The trouble with rituals, however, is that people forget the reasons why they were introduced in the first place; so they continue taking their dips in holy waters even when they all full of unholy shit.
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#245 Posted by mohar11 on January 20, 2007 8:19:34 am
Re: # 244

Best of Civilization

As we know - this dude hardly used bath and moutwash - yet he is the best that any civilization ever produced... Looks can be deceiving.... :)
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#244 Posted by hamidm2 on January 20, 2007 8:13:34 am
Re: # 241

mohar,

.........come on, try and be a little objective .......... we all know that the first step on the road to civilization starts with a bath and then, after hundreds of years, people discover deodrant and mouthwash .......... i think the muslims might have a slight edge in this regard even though most desi muslims (particularly biharis) are not a whole lot better than their unwashed and uncircumcised cousins ..........
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#243 Posted by tahmed32 on January 20, 2007 8:11:54 am
hamidm: I thought you liked white-skins and didnt like dark skins. Look at the pains this guru guy went through to make himself white-skinned for you!! :-)
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#242 Posted by tahmed32 on January 20, 2007 8:09:33 am
ijaz_gul: ``Just for record and no disrepectn she moved on the perifery of the desert, which is also commendable. She did not go into the heart. ``

While you may not have meant any disrespect, the fact is that this belittling the accomplishments of this remarkable woman is mean-spirited and unfair. Mean spirited because it ignores the fact that it ignores the broader spirit of adventure that moved her, and splits hairs. While I commend your own trekking in Pakistan, I know of a number of other individuals who have done similar explorations in Pakistan.

This does not mean that your explorations within Pakistan are not interesting. I would really like to learn more. E.g., What path does one take to get to these sites you mentioned? I assume things are back to normal in Dhera Bugti now, so it is OK to go off the beaten path - most trekking is done in the northern areas, and this is the first time I have heard of someone roaming around the baluch countryside. Any light you can shed on these questions would be appreciated.
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#241 Posted by mohar11 on January 20, 2007 8:07:58 am
Re: # 238

Yep - The first pic is civilization...

second pic is bedouinism, violent tribalism at its worst... :)
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#240 Posted by hamidm2 on January 20, 2007 8:07:53 am


is this civilization ?

``hindoo

the alternative is equally scary even though it doesn`t smell as bad

``haj
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#239 Posted by mohar11 on January 20, 2007 8:06:10 am
Just saw a report you pakis have started importing cancer drugs from india... when hamidm would be down from prostrate cancer in Khan`s Cancer Hospital in Karachi, what do you think is going to save him?.... yep, it would be heeng-laced cancer drugs from India...

Hard as you may try, you can`t run away from heeng... heeng is the future and future is here... :)
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#238 Posted by hamidm2 on January 20, 2007 8:02:46 am


is this civilization ?

``hindoo

little improvement .... no?

``haj
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#237 Posted by mohar11 on January 20, 2007 7:57:47 am
See pakis - brits have been taunting you guys for decades with racial slurs, nobody cared.... but they tried that stunt once on an indian like Shilpa and all he!ll broke loose... Even the Brit Prime Minister stepped in to apologize...

That, my dear pakis, is the power of heeng... Just ask George Allen.... :)
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#236 Posted by Folio on January 20, 2007 7:21:22 am
Sorry guyz for the distraction, dont read this if u like Chowk administrators:

If u like these Chowk Administrators, pl dont read this.


We are fed up with these niggers.

For those who dont know: Two posts were made on boards
1. Wife beating 2. Pakistan`s Democracy. None of the msgs was abusive.

That means no violation of any guidelines. The words didnt contain any abusive words which we normally see them here and the posters were normally overlooked.



Sample: By HP 232 on India`s Foreign Policy board:

``Abey bhootni kay apni maan kay khusam say gaand mara.``


We sent several emails b4 this to Chowk Eunuchs. Now we sent another on the same subject. It may look silly but it looks like that Chowk Chutiyas are deaf-cum-blind or rank Eunuchs.






Quote:

I dont know if it`s a person or a group of persons:

We had been asking for termination of our IDs for good but u guyz never responded to the emails.

We want our IDs both VRV and Folio to be terminated for good.

Emails were sent and u were sitting on them.

Shameless chituya(s).

Mard hai to terminate kar, yah if u dont then confirm that u are eunuch(s)!

Mard(s) or Eunuch(s)??????????????

Unquote

Chowk Administartor(s) Chutiy(s).

P.S: This is no way meant for the guys who founed this site and I feel that founders and administartors are not the same.

reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#235 Posted by ijaz_gul on January 20, 2007 5:54:31 am
Zeemax,
Just for record and no disrepectn she moved on the perifery of the desert, which is also commendable. She did not go into the heart.

This is one of my ilogs I am pasting with due respects to tanishaq.

http://www.chowk.com/show_interactor_page.cgi?membername=ijaz_gul&start=15&end=19&page=4&chapter=1#journal

October 14, 2005

Raheela

Its a sad day as I learn that rescuers in Islamabad were not able to retrieve the body of Raheela Gul, Pakistan`s only woman who had trekked the poles and the entire Thar, Nara and Choolistan deserts in one go. We met briefly North of Khipro in the bitter lakes of Nara desert in March this year. She was one woman amongst a team of Geo TV and local guides. We shared the same passion for mountains and deserts and were dreamers in the same stride. Today she is no more but hope tells me that being a fighter and survivor, she may yet be found alive fighting the rubble of Margalla Towers.

Raheela we are proud of you and remember you.

Could someone guide me how to upload her pic on unplugged, or could do it from her web site

www.raheela.com

reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#234 Posted by bulleya on January 20, 2007 1:12:57 am
..aaaahhhhhh!....the articulate eloquence and unbridled poetic maturity of speech on this site:....the civilized behavior, below, should be enough to prove why one cannot consider south asia to be a civilization....

``Ref HackedPenis.....Abey bhootni kay apni maan kay khusam say gaand mara. I don’t give a fk abt what you had in that godforsaken place Bihar or Vihara. Once a dump always a dump…. .....``

``Abey choot marani kay Khasi…Start from wherever the fk you wanna start as if I care darky dork… Kaalay bhoot…. Abey bhootni kay apni maan kay khusam say gaand mara…. HO HO HO....HP ki gaand mein aag lag gayi hearing about the greatness of bihar. abe haram ke jale, tere ghatia desh mein sirf tujh jaise haraami hi hote hain kya???? MC sala racist chuutiya.``

... i rest my case.......
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#233 Posted by devkant on January 19, 2007 11:55:13 pm
#232 by HP on January 19, 2007 10:58pm PT

``#225 by harimau
Ref HackedPenis #217
“Yes, Bihar indeed would be a good place to start.”
Abey choot marani kay Khasi…Start from wherever the fk you wanna start as if I care darky dork… Kaalay bhoot….

“Bihar, from ``Vihara``, for the temples that dotted the country.”

Abey bhootni kay apni maan kay khusam say gaand mara. I don’t give a fk abt what you had in that godforsaken place Bihar or Vihara. Once a dump always a dump….

HAHAHA! ``


HO HO HO....HP ki gaand mein aag lag gayi hearing about the greatness of bihar. abe haram ke jale, tere ghatia desh mein sirf tujh jaise haraami hi hote hain kya???? MC sala racist chuutiya.
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#232 Posted by HP on January 19, 2007 10:58:11 pm

#225 by harimau
Ref HackedPenis #217
“Yes, Bihar indeed would be a good place to start.”
Abey choot marani kay Khasi…Start from wherever the fk you wanna start as if I care darky dork… Kaalay bhoot….

“Bihar, from ``Vihara``, for the temples that dotted the country.”

Abey bhootni kay apni maan kay khusam say gaand mara. I don’t give a fk abt what you had in that godforsaken place Bihar or Vihara. Once a dump always a dump….

HAHAHA!



reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#231 Posted by zeemax on January 19, 2007 10:53:43 pm
#206 by ijaz_gul

Last year I travelled the entire Nara Desert on foot came and cross country vehicles along this course and ended at Nagar Parkar.

Raheela Gul (late) was trekking the same area around that time. Any acquaintance?

I was told about Raheela in Hunza a few years ago after she had trekked from Gilgit to the base of K-2 through Fairy Meadows leading a group of Japanese trekkers. She was something of a legend in those parts.
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#230 Posted by ijaz_gul on January 19, 2007 10:23:36 pm
Dost,
Yes this part of Indian Rajistan is also part of the Nara Depression or the Nara Desert. About 70% falls in Pakistan and rest in India. Such salt lakes are also in Pakistan in areas like Kallar Kahar, Bannu etc. In fact there are many Harmoons (bitter lakes) in Central Balochistan. Water is extremely brackish and concentrated with soda and ash.

Just to comment on another discussion on the Board, HINDU word was derived from Schinde/Indus, and became a word defining religion very recently. As for origins of modern man, I offer the following: -
1. Cromagnon Man Balochistan Pakistan.
2. Ramapitecus, the first humanoid, Siwalik foothills, Pakistan/Kashmir.
3. Leh River, Once the biggest river on the South Pole Plate, after the tectonic drift became Leh Nullah in Rawalpindi/Islamabad. While moving from Islamabad Airport to Islamabad, you will notice a hill on the left with Unity, Faith and Discipline written. This hill was a humanoid habitation in the pre historic era.
4. Harappa, Mo en Jo Daro and Nara Civilisations.
5. The Throne of Mauryan Empire and the centre of education and learning was at Taxila.
6. Ghandhara Civilisation.

Cheerios
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#229 Posted by tahmed32 on January 19, 2007 7:12:51 pm
Netizen #224 I was referring to the mahabharata given the broad appeal of the mahabharata TV shows. The Gupta period was certainly known for its paintings and arts, and in that sense could be called a ``golden period``. Although I doubt that any period in past history was golden for the ordinary guys. After all, even Saddam Hussein had his ``golden period`` complete with magnificent palaces and other landmarks that were built to give him the same glory as nebuchadnazzer. But during this ``golden period`` half a million iraq children starved (of course this war has turned to be even worse for the average iraqi). The same of course is true of the ``golden era`` of the first four caliphs that the musim extremists talk about.

If there is any truly ``golden era`` for the average joe, it is today. When eradication of poverty is taken more seriously than building palaces or doing artwork for the enjoyment of kings. Anyway.... :-)
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#228 Posted by tahmed32 on January 19, 2007 7:01:14 pm
#226 You have been parroting this for 7 years on chowk.
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#227 Posted by harimau on January 19, 2007 5:39:19 pm
Ref ali_1 #190

[Yes... YES... YES

Hail Harimau.

I`ve said it many times and I`ll say it again. blah, blah, blah....]

Here is what Wikipedia has to say in its entirety about Prophet Mohammad:

From http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muhammad

[Muhammad
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Paedophile]
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#226 Posted by harimau on January 19, 2007 5:35:22 pm
Ref Mullah32 #203

[I am not saying exactly what you say I am, I hasten to add. I am saying is that Indian Civilization is not congruent with Hindu Civilization by any realistic stretch, and BJP propaganda and the popularity of mahabharata plays in India since the 1980`s (I think) notwithstanding. Indian Civilization is a vastly richer mosaic of religions, cultures, traditions, languages, scripts than hinduism alone.]

The only native religions of India of antiquity are Hinduism, Jainism and Buddhism... in that order. Johnny-come-lately Islam had nothing to contribute except the destruction of temples and seats of learning. You probably would consider that a rich form of culture.

Most Indian languages with the exception of the Dravidian languages derive their script from Sanskrit or Pali. In fact Hindu civilization extended to Sri Lanka, Burma and Thailand and to this day their languages are written in scripts derived from Pali. Which happens to be a rational left-to-right script.

The only thing Islam imported into India is pedophilia. Here is what Wikipedia has to say in its entirety about Prophet Mohammad:

From http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muhammad

[Muhammad
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Paedophile]

And of course Richard Francis Burton recorded that in 1847, Karachi had several brothels that employed as many as 4,000 boys. Another rich tradition of Islam.

Choke on that! Or on someone`s dick.
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#225 Posted by harimau on January 19, 2007 5:20:44 pm
Ref HackedPenis #217

[Only the current Sindhi and part of Punjab and NWFP, which were geographically known as Sindh, could claim the Indus civilization. Bharti or the resident of the country called India should look elsewhere for their roots…Bihar is a good place to start….]

Yes, Bihar indeed would be a good place to start.

Bihar, from ``Vihara``, for the temples that dotted the country.

Bihar, where the Mauryas established Pataliputra (modern-day Patna) as their capital in 455 BC.

Bihar, wherein lies Bodh Gaya where Buddha attained enlightenment.

Bihar, where liesin the ruins of the great university of Nalanda, established 427 AD, about which is written:

[Nalanda was one of the world`s first residential universities, i.e., it had dormitories for students. In its heyday it accommodated over 10,000 students and 2,000 teachers. The university was considered an ``architectural masterpiece,`` and was marked by a lofty wall and one gate. Nalanda had eight separate compounds and ten temples, along with many other meditation halls and classrooms. On the grounds were lakes and parks. The library was located in a nine storied building where meticulous copies of texts were produced. The subjects taught at Nalanda University covered every field of learning, and it attracted pupils and scholars from Korea, Japan, China, Tibet, Indonesia, Persia and Turkey. The Tang Dynasty Chinese pilgrim Xuanzang left detailed accounts of the university in the 7th century.

The university was an architectural and environmental masterpiece. It had eight separate compounds, 10 temples, meditation halls, classrooms, lakes and parks. It had a nine-story library where monks meticulously copied books and documents so that individual scholars could have their own collections. It had dormitories for students, perhaps a first for an educational institution, housing 10,000 students in the university’s heyday and providing accommodations for 2,000 professors. Nalanda was also the most global university of its time, attracting pupils and scholars from Korea, Japan, China, Tibet, Indonesia, Persia and Turkey.

A vast amount of what is considered to be Tibetan Buddhism (Vajrayana) actually stems from the late (9th-12th century) Nalanda teachers and traditions. Other forms of Buddhism, like the Mahayana followed in Vietnam, China, Korea and Japan, found their genesis within the walls of the ancient university. Theravada, the other main school of Buddhism, followed in Sri Lanka, Myanmar, Thailand, Cambodia, and elsewhere, and later the mystic Theravada schools also developed here.]

And in case momofukus like you are claiming the Indus Valley civilization as that of the Pakistanis, here is exactly what your momofuku ancestors did to Nalanda:

[In 1193, the Nalanda University complex was sacked by Turkic Muslim invaders under Bakhtiyar Khalji; this event is seen as a milestone in the decline of Buddhism in India. It is said that Khalji asked if there was a copy of the Koran at Nalanda before he sacked it.]

Ah yes, what is a library without The Book to End All Books, Life`s Little Instruction Book, otherwise known as the Koran?

On the other hand, this is what Wikipedia has to say in its entirety about Prophet Mohammad:

From http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muhammad

[Muhammad
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia


Paedophile]
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#224 Posted by Netizen on January 19, 2007 4:00:51 pm
Re: # 219

tahmed:
I completely agree with you that anciet indian civilisation was much more than 20th century hindutva.

``The religion that has come to be known as Hinduism is certainly the oldest and most varied of all the great religions of the world. The word `Hinduism` itself is a geographical term based upon the Sanskrit name for the great river that runs across the northern boundaries of India, known as the Sindhu. For those living on the other side of this river, the entire region to the south-east of the Sindhu, which the Greeks called the Indus, came to be known as the land of the Hindus, and the vast spectrum of faiths that flourished here acquired the generic name Hinduism. In fact, Hinduism calls itself the Sanatana Dharma, the eternal faith, because it is based not upon the teachings of a single preceptor but- on the collective wisdom and inspiration of great seers and sages from the very dawn of Indian civilization.``

ancient Indian civilisation had ``Hindu``, Jain, Buddhist, Christian, animist and agnostic traditions. nevertheless it was a civilisation.


``mahabharata which the BJP touts as being the epitome of the ``glorious past`` of India``

i am not sure of that. mahabharat, th elongest epic in the world was not considered as a glorious past. the glorious ``hindu`` period is considered during the gupta age.

``The Gupta Empire is considered by many scholars to be the ``classical age`` of Hindu and Buddhist art and literature. The Rulers of the Gupta Empire were strong supporters of developments in the arts, architecture, science, and literature. ``

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gupta_Empire
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#223 Posted by tahmed32 on January 19, 2007 3:51:12 pm
dost mittar: the BJP censor has spoken in #220!! Kindly refrain from discussions with pakis, and follow the example of ``paki paki arjun`` and write gibberish instead. :-)
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#222 Posted by tahmed32 on January 19, 2007 3:47:26 pm
HP #217 actually ``Bharat`` was the name of one of a gazillion tribes that came to India, this particular one - living in a small area around delhi - having gotten written up. So we Pakistanis get the land that was originally India (Indus), while Indians get to keep the name. Not a bad deal. :-)
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#221 Posted by Netizen on January 19, 2007 3:39:42 pm
Re: # 217

hp-ji:

Last time I read tahmed`s post, he was firm about non-existence of indian civilisation. but today he was commenting about it. Hence my surprise.

i have no intention to prove/dis-prove pakis of various shapes and colors about ``their`` indian-ness. Especially when almost everyone of them claims to be an illegimate child of hazrat mohammad, hazrat ghauri and/or hazrat abdali.


reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#220 Posted by arjun2 on January 19, 2007 3:30:25 pm
#197 by dost-mittar on January 19, 2007 7:36am PT


You`re wasting your time...

Pakis only want to deny the existence of Indian civilization, something pretty much the world accepts, because nobody associates them with a paki civilization and because they`re just from another-stan, not from a land associated with an ancient civilization...
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#219 Posted by tahmed32 on January 19, 2007 3:27:58 pm
netizen #212 welcome back.

I am afraid every tom, dick and harry in india does know that the subcontinent is rich mosaic that goes way beyond hinduism. The reason for this is easily seen in dost mittar #215 below, where he notes the hindu extremist`s simplistic view that everything before the arrival of muslims in india was some ``glorious hindu era`` and everything after was the ``dark ages of muslim rule``. I will simply add that the muslim extremist`s view is equally simplistic - i.e. the glorious era becomes the dark ages and the dark ages become the glorious era.

And both views, like any view driven by some preconceived notion or ideology, are wrong. The reality is something vastly more interesting.

the tom, dicks and harry`s of india (and pakistan) are clearly heavily influenced by these divergent and equally incorrect views.

Thus, you yourself end your post by talking about ``hindu culture`` - the term ``hindu``, regardless of its roots, obviously refers to a particular religion that did not exist in terms of its basic features more than 3-4 millenia ago even by the largest reasonable stretch : the mahbharata events probably occurred between 2-3 millenia ago, e.g. On the other hand the first individual to even step foot in the subcontinent was here definitely more than 12-15 millenia ago. And the great harappan civilization (not as well known as the babylonian in part due to the inability to decipher their language) was certainly thousands of years before the mahabharata which the BJP touts as being the epitome of the ``glorious past`` of India. I rest my case. :-)
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#218 Posted by arjun2 on January 19, 2007 3:23:03 pm
Jeez Louise...AGAIN...

Army denies US drone behind SWA attack

Our monitoring desk
Pakistan’s military on Friday rebutted claims that a US Predator drone aircraft carried out the initial attack on a suspected Al-Qaeda hideout earlier this week in South Waziristan Agency, reports a private TV channel.
On Tuesday, army spokesman said helicopter gunships struck a cluster of compounds where up to 30 Taliban and Al-Qaeda fighters were based in South Waziristan.
However, tribesmen said a US drone’s missiles destroyed the compounds, and Pakistan helicopter gunships mopped up by firing rockets. “This is wrong. We have already denied it. This is usual that such things are said on such occasions but these are wrong,” army spokesman Shaukat Sultan said.
Villagers said they found just eight bodies - all belonging to men from a team of wood-cutters, who made a living selling charcoal to surrounding towns.
“No foreigner was killed in this attack. Only labourers were killed,” said Awaz Khan, whose son and nephew were among the dead.
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#217 Posted by HP on January 19, 2007 2:04:16 pm

Neti,

The question is that why should ethnic groups in Pakistan; Sindhi, Punjabi, Baloch or Pathan accept a later version of the civilization? All these ethnic groups predate what is now being called the Indian civilization.

The current Geographical configuration of the areas comprised of all these civilizations is called Pakistan. They were called India before and off and on before that, part of the Persian Empire.
The areas that are called India were perhaps Bharat before they became India. India as we all agree is a given name.

India does not translate in to Hindi or Hindu. So if in future India changes its official name to Bharat or Hindustan, would the Indian civilization automatically become Bharati or Hindustani civilization?

Only the current Sindhi and part of Punjab and NWFP, which were geographically known as Sindh, could claim the Indus civilization. Bharti or the resident of the country called India should look elsewhere for their roots…Bihar is a good place to start….




reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#216 Posted by HP on January 19, 2007 1:34:45 pm

Let us revert this discussion back to Indian Foreign policy from the dead lakes and the dead civilizations...So I repeat my post # 41 and let discuss this potential theory here as that would correctly tell us what was Indian`s potential in 1930 and where it is with regards to its foreign policy....

``Indian foreign policy was designed and still fighting to thwart the long held British and American policy to maintain Pakistan as ``a check on Indian potential ``.

Obviously, most of the Indian foreign policy stalwarts (some here too) had no Idea what the Indian potential was.

Indian potential was something first the Brits, and now the American keep as a major secret......

Here is a money quote from potential_null the Idiot Indian foreign policy guru.
“Act as a check on India’s potential” conspiracy theory in a nutshell….

“Pakistan (in the form of a separate nation in its current position, always balancing against India rather than bandwagoning with India) was seen as necessary for the protection of British interests. Subsequently the Americans have taken over the hand the British were playing.

From the Anglo-American perspective, Pakistan’s major utility is to act as a check on India’s potential and an instrument for modulating India`s actions. ``

#212 by Netizen

Netibaba Sindhi Hindi wont make any difference...First DM and now you would like to call us Hindi.. I got no problem with that at all after all there was not going to any hindi without the this Sindhi first...

How about we all revert to our Sindhi roots and call it what it is the Sindhi civilization as in the Indus Civilization...


But lets talk about the potential theory first...


reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#215 Posted by dost_mittar on January 19, 2007 1:29:26 pm
bylleya#208:

You could perhaps call it a ``hindu`` civilisation if it had ended after the advent of Islam in India and India entered a period of darkness thereafter. This is a position only of some extreme hindu nationalists. The continuum of civilization continued; for example, while Urdu is a product of Indian civilisation, it cannot be called a product of the hindu civilisation by any stretch of imagination.
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#214 Posted by AlephNull on January 19, 2007 1:08:22 pm
Maharana # 200

{{Probably the most renowned scholar in the area of cultural and civilizational studies of the entire world is Joseph Needham Campbell.}}

You’ve conflated two different people … you probably meant Joseph J. Campbell, the scholar of comparative mythology.

Joseph Needham was a scholar of Chinese civilization and particularly of its allegedly unbroken record of scientific and technological achievement.
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#213 Posted by AlephNull on January 19, 2007 12:57:57 pm
dost-mittar #211

{{ Last summer, I visited a huge lake (130 kms long) in Ladakh straddling the border of India and China.}}

Probably Panggong-Tso.

{{we were told that the area was once part of the sea.}}

… called the Tethys Sea.
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#212 Posted by Netizen on January 19, 2007 12:52:29 pm
Re: # 203

chacha akhmad:

wah bhai wah!

kya lecture zhad rahe ho.

anyway........
I thought that earlier you were arguing against indian civilisation talking only about ``indian history``. is it that you have now accepted that there ``could be`` something called as an indian civilisation?
maybe i missed some of your posts.

Not withstanding the efforts of NDA govt. to prove that mohenjodaro was linked to vedic religion, every tom, dick and harry in india knows that indian civilisation/culture is rich tapestry of different religions, cultures, traditions, languages...

even thousands of years back different religions were the different sects within hinduism, jainism, buddhism and so many other religious thoughts of the day.

no one is equating indian civilisation solely to ``hindusim``. it never existed even as a word thousands of years earlier. but it could be a way of life....

may be that why even though you (pakis) converted hundreds of years ago but still blame the ``hinduness/banianess`` for the evils in the society.

do you know i know many people who are agonist by faith but hindu by culture.
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#211 Posted by dost_mittar on January 19, 2007 12:20:30 pm
Ijaz:

I don`t know if this fits into your analysis but I am reminded of two episodes during my travels. Three years ago, I went to Jaisalmer in India, probably not far from the areas that you visited. The general belief there is that there was a sea there before it became a desert. The souvenir shops sell artifacts (shells, stones, etc.) believed to be remnants of the sea there. The local words `maru` and `thar` both are said to mean `dead` and people believe that the desert was once a sea.

Last summer, I visited a huge lake (130 kms long) in Ladakh straddling the border of India and China. This lake, at a height of 16000 feet above sea level, is not of fresh water but a salt lake. Once again, we were told that the area was once part of the sea.

These are, of course, not scientific facts, merely legends quoted to us.
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#210 Posted by tahmed32 on January 19, 2007 11:59:05 am
#205 jang: as long as one has a place to take a shower after the dip in the ganga. :-)
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#209 Posted by tahmed32 on January 19, 2007 11:55:45 am
ijaz gul: You have certainly gone off the beaten track here!! I wasnt aware of these caves.
There was indeed an ancient sea that formed I think about 250 million years ago (when India was floating towards the eurasian landmass) and lasted till (I think, around 50-60 million years ago, when the subcontinent closed the gap and the sea-bed was inverted to become the himalay mountains - I am writing the timeline from memory since I need to go somewhere now and dont have time to double check). That is where the sea-shells are from. They have found such remains of a sea-bed in the himalays thousands of feet above sea-level!!

I would very much like to learn about your travels in these areas. Would you consider writing a chowk article describing these caves, particularly because I dont see much on the internet on it??
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#208 Posted by bulleya on January 19, 2007 11:45:57 am
...i think the question comes back to the main point, i.e. can a civilization be defined by relgion alone.....if yes, then india is a singular civilization and always was one (from the time that hinduism arrived in the region)...as hinduism been the majority religion.....

....however, if religion is not a singular criteria, then india is not a civilization, nor was it ever one, as there were too many differing factors between the various groups that constitute the area.......it is a combination of many different civilizations, which differed in all areas, except religion....pakistan is the same.....

...one can then get into the technicalities of whether hindiusm is not a religion, but a dharma etc. and islam is not a religion but a way of life, etc.....however, generally, both hinduism and islam are both considered religion by everyone....
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#207 Posted by tahmed32 on January 19, 2007 11:44:59 am
dm/vrv: Thanks for your posts. Since you touch upon a common theme, let me take the liberty of replying to both here - the common theme is the term India. Sure the ancient greeks and romans (as vrv points out) referred to the term ``India`` to mean the entire sub-continent. The romans got this term from the greeks who got this from....er...Pakistanis. :-) Or at least, people who lived in what is now Pakistan but was then (around 600 BC I think) the easternmost province of the persian achaemaean empire (which, btw, was larger even than the roman empire), and ``India`` is from Indus. Nothing to do with ganges, sorry to say.

But we, the original Indians, dont mind letting you use the name. After all, one of our illustrious sons of the indus valley - painini - also gave you the sanskrit grammer. :-)

PS: Just kidding. But these are indeed facts that I present in the spirit of breaking this logjam where hindu extremists try to equate India with hinduism while muslim extremists try to equate Pakistan with islam.
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#206 Posted by ijaz_gul on January 19, 2007 11:40:06 am
tahmed32,
Yes, I have visited the caves both in Dera Bughti and Dhanasar (Zhob). These are Cro Mognon caves. It appears that around Dera Bughti, a sea once flowed as one can easily find fossils of crabs, herring abd sea horses not to mention various types of shells. Archeologists theorise that the constant pressure of tectonic plates has over time changed the landscape.

Yes, some opine that Harrapa predates Mohen Jo Daro by about 2,000 years.
As for Sarasvati/Nara/Ghaggar/Reini, I have traveled the entire lenght of the course in Pakistan. Last year I travelled the entire Nara Desert on foot came and cross country vehicles along this course and ended at Nagar Parkar. This was once a green plain irrigated by the lost river but a sequence of Tsunamis and shifting of tectonic plates destroyed it. Allah Wala bund trapped the sea inland and desertified the area. Water is extremely brackish in lagoons and still harbours crocs etc.

Some Biblical scholars think that this is the actual river of the Garden of Eden where Adam and Eve lived before they were banished.

I intend posting a comprehensive article on this sometime soon.

Cheerios
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#205 Posted by jang on January 19, 2007 11:37:20 am
#204 attaboy tahmed, come let us take a dip in the ganges and eat some bhangwale pakorey.
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#204 Posted by tahmed32 on January 19, 2007 11:34:51 am
swarrier #198 No problem sir. We all get carried away a bit during a heated discussion. What is important is that we can appreciate all civilizations in the subcontinent while at the same time having a special interest in the traditions we are born into. Whether these civilizations are hindu, muslim, buddhist, harappan or greco-buddhist. :-)
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#203 Posted by tahmed32 on January 19, 2007 11:28:57 am
DrDr: I thought we are chillin` when we come to chowk to begin with. :-)

I am not saying exactly what you say I am, I hasten to add. I am saying is that Indian Civilization is not congruent with Hindu Civilization by any realistic stretch, and BJP propaganda and the popularity of mahabharata plays in India since the 1980`s (I think) notwithstanding. Indian Civilization is a vastly richer mosaic of religions, cultures, traditions, languages, scripts than hinduism alone.
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#202 Posted by jang on January 19, 2007 11:23:03 am
#201 drsab, this is not such a benign argument. this argument in future will be used for wars.
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#201 Posted by DrDr on January 19, 2007 11:03:33 am
This is a very easy argument 2 settle - 4 swarrier & dost-mittar thers an injun civ - 4 tahmed & bulleya there aint - like beauty its in the eye of the beholder.
None of these bullshit arguments affect the facts on the ground so chill out everybody!
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#200 Posted by Maharana on January 19, 2007 10:48:01 am
Probably the most renowned scholar in the area of cultural and civilizational studies of the entire world is Joseph Needham Campbell. He is the author of many books and his conversations with Bill Moyers on the mythologies of various cultures and civilizations are available online.
He refers to indian civilization - be it hindu, buddhist or jain as a continuum rather than as separate entitites. This mindless need to call indian civilization not as a single continuity in space-time is a mere justification for separatists` existence.
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#199 Posted by jang on January 19, 2007 10:46:16 am
paki gymnastics are merely due to the fact that they are muslim.
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content