unflinching idealism ... since 1997 archivessitemapabouthelpfeedback
ideas, identities and interactions
  • Home
  • InFocus
  • Themes
  • Columns
  • Articles
  • Fiction
  • iLogs
  • Gallery
  • Unplugged
  • Writers
  • Interactors
  • Tags
Sign in | Join Chowk
web chowk
  • Article
  • Interact
  • read writer comments
  • add to favorites
  • get rss feeds
  • print
  • email this link

Musharraf's Options: Time Running Out

Saeed Minhas September 1, 2007

Latest comments   flat   threaded   latest   oldest   all
listing 1-16   1 2 3 4

#1 Posted by arjun2 on September 2, 2007 5:57:36 pm
Benazir is blogging on huffpost(the URL is interesting why I'm returning to paki??!!??)

her last line is the first step of meglomania...bilal mushlet of boston said the same thing when his old man took over in 1999..

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/benazir-bhutto/why-im-returning-to-paki_ b_62792.html

Why I'm Returning To Pakistan

I was looking forward to a quiet family holiday in New York this summer with my three children, our dog Maxmillian and my husband, who is being treated for a heart condition that developed while he was a political prisoner in Pakistan from 1996 to 2004. I thought we would go to the theatre and spend time walking in Central Park, as well meeting up with friends for nice, long chatty dinners. But in this surprisingly momentous summer of 2007, our quiet family vacation disappeared as we found ourselves caught up in the media attention on my country Pakistan, and its fast changing political situation.

It is clear to those following events in South Asia that Pakistan is truly at a turning point. Almost a decade of military dictatorship has devastated the basic infrastructure of democracy. Political parties have been assaulted, political leaders arrested, and the judicial system manipulated to force party leaders into exile. NGOs have been under constant attack, especially those that deal with human rights, democratic values and women's rights. The press has been intimidated, with some reporters -- even those that work for papers like the New York Times -- arrested, beaten or made to disappear. Student and labor unions have not been allowed to function. The electoral institutions of the nation have been manipulated by an Election Commission that could not stop rigging and fraud. And in the battle against terrorism, we look on with dismay as the government of Pakistan ceded sections of our nation that previously had been governed by the rule of law to Taliban sympathizers and to Al Qaeda, making Pakistan the Petri dish of the international terrorist movement.

But the most dangerous manifestation of this retreat from democracy has been a growing sense of hopelessness of the people of Pakistan, and a total disillusionment with the political system's ability to address their daily problems. The social sector has festered -- underfinanced and relegated to the back burner of national policy. All the indicators of quality of life have spiraled down, from employment to education to housing to health care. And as people's sense of disillusionment has grown, there has been a corresponding growth in the spread of religious and political extremism. The failure of the regime has made our citizens open to extra-governmental experimentation with fanaticism. This has clearly been manifest in the spread of politicized madrassas, schools in which the curriculum incorporates xenophobia, bigotry and often para-military terrorist training. But poor parents who cannot feed or clothe their children entrust them to these kinds of schools, so their children may be fed and housed.

The growth of the madrassas is but one important signal that extremism has been making inroads against moderation amongst the Pakistani polity. I have always believed that the battle between extremism and moderation is the underlying battle for the very soul of Pakistan. Yet moderation can prevail against the extremists only if democracy flourishes and the social sector improves the quality of life of the people. In 2007, I sensed that the decade of dictatorship was threatening to undermine the moderate majority of Pakistan, those people committed to pluralism, to education, to technology -- in other words, those committed to Pakistan taking its place among the community of civilized nations as a leader in the 21st century. Under democracy, the extremists had been marginalized in the past, never receiving more than 11% of the vote in an election. But under dictatorship, Pakistan was edging toward extremism, chaos, and sliding towards a failed state.

My party [the Pakistan Peoples Party] was engaged in a dialogue with the regime of General Musharraf, but discussions didn't move the regime concretely toward democratic reform. In the summer of 2007, after the reinstatement of the Chief Justice of Pakistan and the birth of judicial activism, the dialogue with General Musharraf took a more substantive turn. It seemed now that the country had an opportunity to peacefully transition to democracy, which is critical for the other war -- the war of moderation against extremism -- to succeed. I had a choice. Engage in dialogue, or turn toward the streets. I knew that street protests against the Musharraf dictatorship could lead to the deaths of hundreds. I thought about the choice before me very carefully. I chose dialogue; I chose negotiation; I chose to find a common ground that would unite all the moderate elements of Pakistan for a peaceful transfer to a workable political system that was responsive to the needs of the 160 million people of Pakistan whose empowerment is critical to the success of both governing and the fight against terrorism.

I know that some in Pakistan, including those in political parties were so embittered with the military regime that they wanted the door of dialogue shut. But from the very beginning my goal was and remains to guarantee a free and open electoral process that would provide for a legitimate Parliament and provincial assemblies that would then select, in a constitutional process, a civilian President who understands that in a parliamentary democracy, the parliament is supreme. I wasn't negotiating for a guaranteed outcome, I was negotiating for a guaranteed process. That was the goal at the beginning. That is the goal now. Are we making progress towards that goal? I still am unable to say. There are many elements, in particular those sympathisers in the ruling Party and Government who enabled the extremists and militants to expand their influence in my country who are fearful of the return of the PPP and a rollback of the terrorist forces that have gained strength since my government was overthrown in 1996. They want to scuttle a process that could see the emergence of a moderate Pakistan. So it has been a roller coaster ride. Some times the dialogue moves forward with General Musharaf . But then he consults his colleagues in the ruling alliance and retracts from confidence building measures promised for a fair electoral process.

As the presidential and parliamentary elections approach, I am making plans with my supporters to return to Pakistan. I know that it is critical for Pakistan to return to a democratic way of life so that the people's problems can be addressed. When people are partners with government, they stand up to defend their communities against terrorists, criminals and negative forces.

My stay in New York wasn't exactly the family vacation I had planned, but it was a critical period of weeks that could very well determine the future of Pakistan. I long ago realized that my personal life was to be subjugated to my political responsibilities. When my democratically elected father, Prime Minister Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto was arrested in 1977 and subsequently murdered, the mantle of leadership of the Pakistan Peoples Party, our nation's largest, nationwide grassroots political structure, was suddenly thrust upon me. It was not the life I planned, but it is the life I have. My husband and children accept and understand that my political responsibilities to the people of Pakistan come first, as painful as that personally is to all of us. I would like to be planning my son's move to his first year at college later this month, but instead I am planning my return to Pakistan and my party's parliamentary election campaign.

I didn't choose this life. It chose me.
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#2 Posted by Urstruly on September 2, 2007 6:37:25 pm

Its a beautiful thing

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/south_asia/6966467.stm

reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#3 Posted by echoboom on September 2, 2007 6:50:24 pm
Urstruly:
Thanks.

It is a comfort to the eyes , that picture. A fauji being Kicked & the picture is splashed all across the wordld.

Here too the brilliant bengalis are far ahead of us. No wonder they have never been goray-kay-ghulaams...and kicked our na-paak fauj in the nuts in 1971.

When will our Cantonment Kuttaas start getting this overdue Kuttaa treatment they so much deserve.
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#4 Posted by arjun2 on September 2, 2007 6:58:13 pm
#2 Posted by Urstruly on September 2, 2007 6:37:25 pm

YOu are not bangladeshis..the canine traits that echoboom decries are stronger in you people...

Take a look at this...allah's army hung AQK out to dry to save its own behind...

Book claims Pak N-plan threat to world peace

By our correspondent

LONDON: General Pervez Musharraf had agreed to arrest Dr A Q Khan only after striking a secret deal with US deputy secretary of state Richard Armitage in 2004 that his own army generals involved in illegal nuclear trade would not be touched and most importantly, that he himself would be accepted by the Americans to rule Pakistan in his military uniform.

Extracts from the book published by Sunday Times reveal that during Musharraf-Armitage meeting at Islamabad in 2004 it was agreed that A Q Khan and his aides would be arrested and blamed for “privately” engaging in proliferation. The country’s military elite – who had sponsored Khan’s work and encouraged sales of technology to reduce their reliance on American aid – was left untouched.

After this meeting between the two, the Americans decided to support Musharraf in uniform and Musharraf made A Q Khan confess his crimes on television. However, as part of the deal, Pakistan military generals who were members of Dr A Q Khan black market network since it started selling nuclear technology were not touched.

A senior Musharraf aide described it disingenuously as “the most embarrassing moment in the president’s life” – not because of the evidence but because he had felt Pakistan was on a long leash as it was integral to the Americans’ war on terror.
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#5 Posted by arjun2 on September 2, 2007 7:00:13 pm
another things messers urstruly and boomboom..whoever replaces mushy, it's like putting a different leash on the same old dog..

Here we have nawaz promising to do what mushy is doing and more..which means there's no end to pakis being given a free vacation to club gitmo...

Terror war will be in safe hands, says Nawaz
‘Democratic govt can effectively fight terror with support of parliament’
WASHINGTON: The US-led war on terror will be in safe hands if democracy returns to Pakistan, exiled Pakistan Muslim League (PML-N) leader Nawaz Sharif said on Sunday as he prepares to defy the military regime by returning home.

“It’s very simple: we’re all against terror. I am against terror as much as anybody else in this world,” Nawaz told CNN from London. He recapped his “excellent rapport” with then US president Bill Clinton on fighting extremism before he was ousted as prime minister by President Pervez Musharraf nearly eight years ago.

“You can’t fight terror as the way Mr Musharraf is fighting. He needs the threat of terror for his own survival. We will fight out of conviction,” Sharif added. “So I think a democratic government can effectively fight terror with the support of parliament, with the support of the people of the country, which is of course not there with Mr Musharraf.”
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#6 Posted by teshah on September 2, 2007 9:29:23 pm
Does any body know how much investment was made in this a.bomb business from the public account?
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#7 Posted by abu_safwaan on September 2, 2007 9:34:19 pm
Chacha boom boom....beautiful words..very soon inshAllah..jab arzayy khuda kayy kabayy sayy sab butt uthwayeyy jayeingay..
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#8 Posted by cliftonbridge on September 2, 2007 9:47:05 pm
echo sahab and abu...do you think BB and NS are really going to stand up for pakistani autonomy? why? .... i have very very low expectations. If they dont run us into the ground again with rampant corruption negligence and theft like their prior stints i'll be grateful.
Its not only the military that has to be leashed in Pakistan...haq tu tub ho if most of the prior generation of politicians just died in their sleep. Useless pack of retarded dogs from what i remember ...what do you remember?
Echo sahab i am serious, please remind me what either NS and BB have ever done for our country because i am depressed out of my mind at the thought of having to see their theiving faces again. I am asking you because you are honestly smarter than me, and I could use some cheering up.
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#9 Posted by abu_safwaan on September 2, 2007 9:53:21 pm
yarr pulya baji..at some level i share ur cinicism...bb especially i have no doubt is bad news..ns is moron..but his brother is a good admin..n they have some individuals in thier part that give an impression that they realize that the ppl of pakistan won't take it anymore..i cud be wrong but i reckon ns has some good ppl around him.
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#10 Posted by cliftonbridge on September 2, 2007 9:55:29 pm
abu may the future prove you right and me wrong ! hum bhi dekhain ge !
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#11 Posted by echoboom on September 2, 2007 10:03:40 pm
Cliffy:8
this got posted on another aa-tickle (aa Gud-gudee kar)
____________________________________________________________

Nawaz Kameen aur Baizameer CAN do nothing except try to prove more loyal to their White-Bhagwaan.

Pakistan needs a lancet to let the black-blood from its vein
flow out until the westoxicated poison is completely drained from its festering sores.

"tariay azaar kaa charaa naheeN nishtar kay sivaa"...Faiz said it long long time ago.

Until & Unless Fauji Foundation & Bahria are dismantled, NLC
( national logistics cell) the ones who issued tenders without competition for the bridge that was constructed 3 weeks a ago & collapsed & until & Unless all Cantonment Kuttaas Kennels called DEfense & Until &n Unless the Cantonment & Colonies are not turned over to those selling meat & groceries [the hardworking dhoti shalwaar huqquaa paan-wallaas, with mullah-looks] & at the ORIGINAL prices...

Until & Unless

Every sign & trace of Western "culture" must be eradicated to make the land Paak again.

We will keep working at the same salary.
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#12 Posted by cliftonbridge on September 2, 2007 10:07:12 pm
:) echo sahab i would love to eradicate all culture altogether from pakistan and the whole world. Culture itself smells to the high heavens. Phir bus naam rahe ga Allah ka (for us ...others may call it justice)! and may we all live in peace and justice from then on regardless of gender economics and religion.

So i take it neither you nor me are celebrating at this point ? :(
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#13 Posted by cliftonbridge on September 2, 2007 10:15:15 pm
* nor i*
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#14 Posted by echoboom on September 2, 2007 10:23:47 pm
Cliffy:
Let me share a real painful observation with you.

Who among us is not familiar with the stampede which occurs at Desi parties when announcement for food is made. This phenomena is unique ONLY to Indians & Pakistanis.

Now I can assure you that maybe 50 or maybe 80 years ago none of us were like that.

This single observation of carries within it a 1000 years of "reasearch" & "schlorship".

Those who do it are not the deprived ones. They are invariably our "respected" "parRhay-likhhay" & "professional" ones.

We used to, even as a joke, swing to two extremes.

One was the "pehlay aap ones" who were ridiculed about missing their trains.

the other ones were the ones who were so "adventurous" that
they boarded the train themselves instead of the ones who they came to see off at the station.

That SUMS up Pakistan of today & you know who won & who is always riding the trains now.

But I am more disturbed for Pakistanis , especially Muslims.

Forming a Queue is a cardinal requirement for these people during Namaz...& they do not practice it in daily lives.

They are painfully punctual for prayers & Ramzaan...& but in other affairs being on time is a joke with us.

" Jis qaum ko thhee chaar nikahoaN kee ijazat"

the other line is pretty vulgar..but 100% true.
__________________________________________________________

Al-Muntazar , Al-Muntazar..Imam Mehdi..I am Al-Muntazar


reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#15 Posted by saima_gul on September 2, 2007 10:33:13 pm
an informative essay based on sources.
All military dictators in Pakistan have shown consistency in their lack of knowledge of military-politico sociology in Pakistan, the latest being the embattled Mussarraf, Only if he had learned and cared to listen to those he side lined in due course.
His high 7 Point Agenda stands distorted and decimated as he makes a political mess in the murky waters of Dealing and Wheeler Dealing.
Is it not a shame that both Mush and Benazir focus on yet another term, and not resolving the outstanding issues that Pakistan faces?
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#16 Posted by viqarm on September 2, 2007 11:16:57 pm
Why does the author think that the biggest general is out of options? If only he refuses to succumb to his obsession with occupying the sadarati kursi, which is not going to mean a whole lot in the next govt any way, he might yet discover that he is still very much in demand - not least by the so called champions of the "gharib awam".

Let him announce that he is stepping down, dissolving the assemblies, and calling for new elections. Let us see if the "Chauries of Gujrat" and the lotas in their party can hack it in free and fair elections? Honestly, if the agencies stayed out of it, neither them nor MMA can come anywhere close to repeating 2002.

Dokhtare-mashriq will have her hands full with the ex-tiger of Punjab, now a lion thanks to the new found hair transplant, and she may be amenable to come to some accomodation with mqm to at least secure Sindh, and a coalition at the center with other smaller parties. She may want to make use of the biggest general's good offices, not only to ensure that the agencies don't do a hatchet job on her party's vote, but also to keep mqm on-side. This might mean dangling the promise of a civilian sadarati kursi for him in the next dispensation, if he is amenable to helping her.

The biggest general is seemingly out of options only because, instead of wanting to be free, he would rather be a prisoner of the kursi and continue to shiver in his boots...
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
listing 1-16   1 2 3 4

Interact Index

    #56 jayp
    #55 nasah
    #54 Naqshbandi
    #53 tahmed32
    #52 tahmed32
    #51 tahmed32
    #50 hamidm2
    #49 arjun2
    #48 bjkumar
    #47 thinkingstorm
    #46 thinkingstorm
    #45 teshah
    #44 echoboom
    #43 anil
    #42 abu_safwaan
    #41 thinkingstorm
    #40 thinkingstorm
    #39 Naqshbandi
    #38 Naqshbandi
    #37 thinkingstorm
    #36 HP
    #35 HP
    #34 hamidm2
    #33 Naqshbandi
    #32 tahmed32
    #31 echoboom
    #30 tahmed32
    #29 thinkingstorm
    #28 dost_mittar
    #27 jang
    #26 Urstruly
    #25 Urstruly
    #24 Urstruly
    #23 arjun2
    #22 tahmed32
    #21 dost_mittar
    #20 hamidm2
    #19 jayp
    #18 muqaddam
    #17 thinkingstorm
    #16 viqarm
    #15 saima_gul
    #14 echoboom
    #13 cliftonbridge
    #12 cliftonbridge
    #11 echoboom
    #10 cliftonbridge
    #9 abu_safwaan
    #8 cliftonbridge
    #7 abu_safwaan
    #6 teshah
    #5 arjun2
    #4 arjun2
    #3 echoboom
    #2 Urstruly
    #1 arjun2

Latest Interacts

  • Dash_Dot: ekalavya, dont get me... Government Wins Manmohan Singh
  • vengatramanan: The agreement would not... Government Wins Manmohan Singh
  • Dash_Dot: Re: # 14 Ekalavya,... Government Wins Manmohan Singh
  • zeemax: What's this news about... Government Wins Manmohan Singh
  • nkg: Re: # 228 Tahmed.... Mahabharata is... Dhokha and Being a
  • Eklavya: Dash, Pakistan has every... Government Wins Manmohan Singh
  • dost_mittar: Shah2#216: You make some relevant... Dhokha and Being a
  • Dash_Dot: I didnot expect to... Government Wins Manmohan Singh

THEMES

  • Pakistan's Struggle for Democracy
  • The Indian Story
  • Indo-Pak Relations
  • Personal Narratives
  • Religion Today
  • War on Terror
  • Role of Media
  • Call for Social Change
  • Hold Them Accountable
  • Environment and Us
  • Way of Life
more »

Top 5 Articles This Week

  • Popular
  • Dhokha and Being a Muslim in India
  • Why is Karachi Turning Into a Sell-Out?
  • Time for Musharraf to Quit
  • Fields Of Joy
  • What's In a Name?
  • Featured
  • There are a Lot of Monkeys
  • White Charade
  • Words of a Woman
  • FOX News and the Smelly Shoes
  • Dilemmas of Creative Children
  • 10 Years Ago
  • Chowk Tales I
  • Sobriquets, Pseudonyms, and the Like
  • Phool Na Loon to Kiya Karoon?
  • Professor Abdus Salam
  • Talks, Talks and More Talks

Write on Chowk Interact Guidelines Privacy policy Terms Contact

Copyright © 1997 - 2008 chowk.com. All Rights Reserved
Reproduction of material on any www.chowk.com pages without prior written permissions is strictly prohibited