unflinching idealism ... since 1997 archivessitemapabouthelpfeedback
all are welcome to read, write and think
  • Home
  • InFocus
  • Themes
  • Columns
  • Articles
  • Fiction
  • iLogs
  • Gallery
  • Unplugged
  • Writers
  • Interactors
  • Tags
Sign in | Join Chowk
web chowk
  • Article
  • Interact
  • read writer comments
  • add to favorites
  • get rss feeds
  • print
  • email this link

The Irreverent Hero Islam Forgot

William Dalrymple March 19, 2008

Latest comments   flat   threaded   latest   oldest   all
listing 128-144   1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11

#260 Posted by zeemax on March 25, 2008 11:54:28 am
#258 Posted by tahir,

If you must proceed in that direction, wear an Imam-Zamin--whatever that is.

I'm sure you mean a condom by saying Imam-Zamin. No, Sir, if Mrs. Hamidm2 exists, she would be quite happy without one.

About his teenage daughters (if they exist) would certainly insist on the guy wearing one. Though I remember and respect Hamidm2's assertion once that how could I say such things about my 'Bhanji/bhateejis'? I won't. That was a fair demand by hamidm2.
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#259 Posted by tahir on March 25, 2008 11:25:53 am
Re: # 204

That 'P' thing is actually Pakistan-envy which makes many Islam-bashers on this site blush.

The Western idea of religion is flirtatious Greeko-Roman gods and goddesses, capitalism, communism, and many more silly 'isms'. Ah! Lenon, Marx, Mao and others.

Spend less time at the Sydney Opera House please.

reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#258 Posted by tahir on March 25, 2008 11:08:47 am
Re: # 199
You don't appear to have much faith in Ham-Damn2. Are you sure the Mrs. is not a fictional character meant to ensnare innocent men?

If you must proceed in that direction, wear an Imam-Zamin--whatever that is.
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#257 Posted by tahir on March 25, 2008 10:58:37 am
Re: # 196
Thanks for your comment ["that is a great point (and only you appear to have made it here) - that the true Quaid-e-Azam can only be Prophet Muhammad"]

When I propounded this to hard-core Pakistani-Deobandis, they were initially taken aback but then smiled generously and hugged me. You too are very kind in paying compliments Mr.Eklavya. Of course, 'deen' seperated from 'siyasat' degenerates into 'Changayzi'--so said poetic Allama Muhammad Iqbal.

I remember seeing somewhere a picture of Mr.Jinnah relaxing on a bench in a park, wearing a suit and two-tone shoes--very different from the 'official pictures' in our textbooks.

If only he could return to give a taste of his two-tone shoes to these clowns who lord over us...

Regards.

reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#256 Posted by anil on March 25, 2008 10:14:07 am
Re: # 245

Tahmed sahib:

"... this simple concept makes religion a liberating force rather than an oppressive one...."

Would you agree to say that let us use "human mind" instead of "religion" in this statement?

Supremacy of mind not only matter, but concept of God, itself is a state-of-mind. Just belief in religious fundamentalism is another state-of-mind.

Many may have enslaved their mind, and thus can never understand. Irrespective who they are Hamidm or Massaddi Mian.
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#255 Posted by HP on March 25, 2008 10:08:50 am
#253 Posted by masadi
“Things are getting interesting and will probably get a whole lot bloodier if the Americans don't get what they want,.”

These are what I call the obvious conclusions given the historical US approach in matters like the one on hand. These tricks work with the army and generals as they don’t understand what public support means and Generals give up quickly or resort to blackmail (that is what mush has been doing for the last 7 years).

In Pakistan’s case admitting defeat would be the last thing in the US mind and all those things that you mentioned mean admitting defeat in Pakistan.

There are still many pieces of puzzle that have not been defined clearly. For sure there are officers in the army that are supporting NS. The Generals and the US know that too. Any army action or Martial Law could mean civil war in Pakistan. Now the US might love that but we still don’t know whether the Pak army as a unit would go for any US forced solution that might start the breakup of the army itself.

Many people think the Generals would do anything for the US but since the Sept. 11, we are watching many fissure points in the Pakistani society. I doubt that the army is immune from resulting disputes and would outright accept any decision from the Generals or the US that would be considered unpatriotic by many in the army itself.

Pakistani politicians and the army have been dealing with the US for a long time and know pretty well how the US operates. The politicians are finally in a position to go eyeball to eyeball with the army and US and at this time I think they are going to take chances!

The WoT drama would go down considerably come Jan 20th, So the politicians now have to find a way to deal with the US for another six months or so and the way to do that is not by acquiesce but by deferring!
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#254 Posted by Eklavya on March 25, 2008 10:08:01 am
"this simple concept makes religion a liberating force rather than an oppressive one."

Absolutely! I have repeatedly emphasized that point, since it is so different from what many outsiders seem to expect.
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#253 Posted by masadi on March 25, 2008 9:10:56 am
HP writes "It will be hard for the PPP even in its own backyard to go against NS on this issue."

Things are getting interesting and will probably get a whole lot bloodier if the Americans don't get what they want, eventually prepping for the Iran invasion they will opt for "liberating" the Western parts of Pakistan, unfortunately the turmoil for the people of Pakistan will continue for the near future. This "move" by the Americans and its welcome coverage by the media was another step in the right direction for the people- it merely shows that what is relatively easier to accomplish with the Pakistan Army is getting a bit more complicated and they are getting ever more jumpy- hence such "mistakes"- we hope and pray that these "mistakes" continue in the future....


g'night...
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#252 Posted by zeemax on March 25, 2008 9:02:37 am
#251 Posted by HP,

Thank you.
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#251 Posted by HP on March 25, 2008 8:14:22 am
Refering to asadi’s posts.

I think the US made the worst diplomatic move in Pakistan by sending its top two diplomats at the wrong time.

They needed to wait this out. It was clear from the oath ceremony and NS meeting with John that situation is getting grimmer out there in Islamabad. NS brought in the Parliament in the whole discussion thus tying up everyone’s hands in PPP or any other forces outside.

NS has raised the stakes. I heard Saudi Arabia is pressuring him to come to the Jeddah for discussions. He is resisting that too. Eventually he will go but not until he has tied the whole thing in knots for the army and US.

Something I wanna say here: Besides his supporters in Punjab, the ANP supporters and even the PPP supporters in Sindh and the Baloch support him in his approach in dealing with the US. It will be hard for the PPP even in its own backyard to go against NS on this issue.

Apparently, his message to the US is: get rid of Mush and we will talk to you. If that means confrontation with the army, he will probably go for it and that alone would be enough to make the army back off.


reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#250 Posted by zeemax on March 25, 2008 7:39:58 am
#249 Posted by masadi,

it was a firm and polite rebuff, masadi. This time this idiot got no protocol, and met Nawaz Sharif in Frontier House in Islamabad instead of the US embassy as the previous Government.
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#249 Posted by masadi on March 25, 2008 7:22:47 am
majumdar writes "As per your analysis what is the purpose of this visit? And the likely outcome?"

Samosa and chai first and foremost, don't want to digress from the sage (of the sewer) Hamid's analysis then

i) keep fighting the war on terror in other words maintain the status quo and don't get any false ideas about your soverignty or challenging the military, if you don't comply we intervene

ii) Forget about the restoration of the judiciary, (like I said earlier it sets a dangerous precident for military rule in Pakistan)

outcome: i) status quo ii) martial law iii)US intervention in the Western parts with the related fireworks that are persuasion tools used by the American using the mullah who "hops to" whenever called.

zee writes "politely"

why politely? A go "F" yourself and your mama would have been more appropriate
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#248 Posted by zeemax on March 25, 2008 7:09:54 am
masadi/majumdar,

First thing Negroponte did was to meet Nawaz Sharif, who's not even in the cabinet. Soundless clips were shown on TV, and the body languages were quite revealing.

Negroponte was shown the door, politely.
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#247 Posted by CreateAlpha on March 25, 2008 6:12:13 am
Here is masadi and CW Mills discussing US Elite and Peons on the West. Enjoy

http://youtube.com/watch?v=xq0YSRAXj4w
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#246 Posted by tahmed32 on March 25, 2008 5:57:44 am
masadi #243 no you twit, i did not red-flag your posts.
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#245 Posted by tahmed32 on March 25, 2008 5:56:12 am
eklavya sahib: while appreciating your taking the time to defend my honor before hamidm's dastardly references to me as doorknob, i would much rather you use your precious time to consider and discuss the substance of what i wrote to dr cheema concerning "religious" vs "philosophical" God.

I do agree with the important point you make to dr. cheema - that given the idea of individual responsibility to God, it does not matter if what I write is not the religion understood by many. And also i would like you to consider the implication - this simple concept makes religion a liberating force rather than an oppressive one.
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
listing 128-144   1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11

Interact Index

    #388 ISlamIslam
    #387 vengatramanan
    #386 Eklavya
    #385 guru
    #384 MantoLives
    #383 nkg
    #382 akcheema
    #381 akcheema
    #380 Eklavya
    #379 akcheema
    #378 Eklavya
    #377 ajeya
    #376 ajeya
    #375 ajeya
    #374 Eklavya
    #373 tahmed32
    #372 Eklavya
    #371 Eklavya
    #370 Eklavya
    #369 tahmed32
    #368 tahmed32
    #367 guru
    #366 Eklavya
    #365 vengatramanan
    #364 vengatramanan
    #363 masadi
    #362 Molaga
    #361 vengatramanan
    #360 vengatramanan
    #359 tahir
    #358 tahir
    #357 MantoLives
    #356 tahir
    #355 MantoLives
    #354 tahir
    #353 tahir
    #352 tahir
    #351 nkg
    #350 nkg
    #349 guru
    #348 treetop
    #347 nkg
    #346 guru
    #345 masadi
    #344 masadi
    #343 masadi
    #342 masadi
    #341 bjkumar
    #340 MantoLives
    #339 MantoLives
    #338 akcheema
    #337 masadi
    #336 masadi
    #335 masadi
    #334 MantoLives
    #333 masadi
    #332 masadi
    #331 MantoLives
    #330 MantoLives
    #329 majumdar
    #328 anil
    #327 peonofthewest
    #326 peonofthewest
    #325 bjkumar
    #324 VRV
    #323 HP
    #322 Eklavya
    #321 guru
    #320 bjkumar
    #319 CreateAlpha
    #318 guru
    #317 treetop
    #316 CreateAlpha
    #315 anil
    #314 masadi
    #313 MantoLives
    #312 masadi
    #311 masadi
    #310 masadi
    #309 MantoLives
    #308 CreateAlpha
    #307 masadi
    #306 pakistan3
    #305 MantoLives
    #304 masadi
    #303 MantoLives
    #302 Eklavya
    #301 peonofthewest
    #300 masadi
    #299 peonofthewest
    #298 masadi
    #297 masadi
    #296 masadi
    #295 masadi
    #294 masadi
    #293 anil
    #292 akcheema
    #291 VRV
    #290 tahir
    #289 akcheema
    #288 tahir
    #287 tahir
    #286 tahir
    #285 tahir
    #284 tahir
    #283 tahir
    #282 tahir
    #281 tahir
    #280 masadi
    #279 akcheema
    #278 tahmed32
    #277 hamidm2
    #276 tahmed32
    #275 tahmed32
    #274 peonofthewest
    #273 tahmed32
    #272 Eklavya
    #271 CreateAlpha
    #270 akcheema
    #269 Eklavya
    #268 akcheema
    #267 akcheema
    #266 akcheema
    #265 Eklavya
    #264 anil
    #263 tahmed32
    #262 tahmed32
    #261 hamidm2
    #260 zeemax
    #259 tahir
    #258 tahir
    #257 tahir
    #256 anil
    #255 HP
    #254 Eklavya
    #253 masadi
    #252 zeemax
    #251 HP
    #250 zeemax
    #249 masadi
    #248 zeemax
    #247 CreateAlpha
    #246 tahmed32
    #245 tahmed32
    #244 majumdar
    #243 masadi
    #242 masadi
    #241 tahmed32
    #240 masadi
    #239 masadi
    #238 masadi
    #237 tahmed32
    #236 tahmed32
    #235 Eklavya
    #234 akcheema
    #233 akcheema
    #232 akcheema
    #231 akcheema
    #230 akcheema
    #229 hamidm2
    #228 zeemax
    #227 akcheema
    #226 akcheema
    #225 akcheema
    #224 tahmed32
    #223 tahmed32
    #222 tahmed32
    #221 akcheema
    #220 tahmed32
    #219 akcheema
    #218 akcheema
    #217 tahmed32
    #216 tahmed32
    #215 tahmed32
    #214 akcheema
    #213 Naqshbandi
    #212 bjkumar
    #211 CreateAlpha
    #210 Eklavya
    #209 tahmed32
    #208 CreateAlpha
    #207 Eklavya
    #206 CreateAlpha
    #205 VRV
    #204 akcheema
    #203 Eklavya
    #202 CreateAlpha
    #201 rajsinghi1
    #200 Eklavya
    #199 zeemax
    #198 rajsinghi1
    #197 Eklavya
    #196 Eklavya
    #195 tahir
    #194 CreateAlpha
    #193 tahir
    #192 tahir
    #191 tahir
    #190 tahir
    #189 guru
    #188 vengatramanan
    #187 zeemax
    #186 zeemax
    #185 zeemax
    #184 zeemax
    #183 masadi
    #182 Naqshbandi
    #181 masadi
    #180 masadi
    #179 akcheema
    #178 anil
    #177 majumdar
    #176 akcheema
    #175 akcheema
    #174 majumdar
    #173 zeemax
    #172 akcheema
    #171 zeemax
    #170 zeemax
    #169 akcheema
    #168 zeemax
    #167 akcheema
    #166 hamidm2
    #165 akcheema
    #164 hamidm2
    #163 zeemax
    #162 akcheema
    #161 zeemax
    #160 akcheema
    #159 zeemax
    #158 tahir
    #157 tahir
    #156 tahir
    #155 tahir
    #154 tahir
    #153 masadi
    #152 nkg
    #151 akcheema
    #150 hamidm2
    #149 bjkumar
    #148 akcheema
    #147 tahmed32
    #146 tahmed32
    #145 anil
    #144 akcheema
    #143 tahmed32
    #142 anil
    #141 tahmed32
    #140 akcheema
    #139 tahmed32
    #138 tahmed32
    #137 akcheema
    #136 anil
    #135 tahmed32
    #134 akcheema
    #133 bjkumar
    #132 bjkumar
    #131 akcheema
    #130 tahmed32
    #129 akcheema
    #128 bjkumar
    #127 akcheema
    #126 akcheema
    #125 akcheema
    #124 bjkumar
    #123 tahmed32
    #122 tahmed32
    #121 akcheema
    #120 CreateAlpha
    #119 tahmed32
    #118 tahmed32
    #117 anil
    #116 tahmed32
    #115 hamidm2
    #114 Naqshbandi
    #113 akcheema
    #112 akcheema
    #111 akcheema
    #110 hamidm2
    #109 GT
    #108 hamidm2
    #107 GT
    #106 hamidm2
    #105 GT
    #104 hamidm2
    #103 hamidm2
    #102 tahmed32
    #101 tahmed32
    #100 zeemax
    #99 tahmed32
    #98 tahmed32
    #97 tahmed32
    #96 zeemax
    #95 tahmed32
    #94 hamidm2
    #93 zeemax
    #92 zeemax
    #91 hamidm2
    #90 zeemax
    #89 zeemax
    #88 zeemax
    #87 hamidm2
    #86 hamidm2
    #85 zeemax
    #84 hamidm2
    #83 tahir
    #82 zeemax
    #81 bubba
    #80 hamidm2
    #79 hamidm2
    #78 zeemax
    #77 hamidm2
    #76 zeemax
    #75 Eklavya
    #74 zeemax
    #73 tahmed32
    #72 tahmed32
    #71 zeemax
    #70 hamidm2
    #69 masadi
    #68 tahmed32
    #67 hamidm2
    #66 hamidm2
    #65 masadi
    #64 masadi
    #63 hamidm2
    #62 Eklavya
    #61 zeemax
    #60 tahmed32
    #59 tahmed32
    #58 zeemax
    #57 hamidm2
    #56 hamidm2
    #55 tahmed32
    #54 zeemax
    #53 hamidm2
    #52 akcheema
    #51 tahmed32
    #50 majumdar
    #49 akcheema
    #48 tahmed32
    #47 tahmed32
    #46 tahmed32
    #45 tahmed32
    #44 bjkumar
    #43 hamidm2
    #42 akcheema
    #41 treetop
    #40 tahmed32
    #39 akcheema
    #38 akcheema
    #37 akcheema
    #36 hamidm2
    #35 tahmed32
    #34 zeemax
    #33 hamidm2
    #32 Eklavya
    #31 khurram
    #30 khurram
    #29 zeemax
    #28 tahmed32
    #27 hamidm2
    #26 tahmed32
    #25 iron_mask
    #24 iron_mask
    #23 Naqshbandi
    #22 akcheema
    #21 akcheema
    #20 Eklavya
    #19 Eklavya
    #18 akcheema
    #17 bulleya
    #16 akcheema
    #15 akcheema
    #14 hamzaad
    #13 ahmedmadani
    #12 mahfari
    #11 Ras
    #10 Leadenwinter
    #9 jayp
    #8 akcheema
    #7 VRV
    #6 Eklavya
    #5 ShoreSahib
    #4 Naqshbandi
    #3 einsteinwallah
    #2 bulleya
    #1 jayp

Latest Interacts

  • anil: Re: # 42 Dost sahib: I... Government Wins Manmohan Singh
  • dost_mittar: dehliwala#48: I am not a... Government Wins Manmohan Singh
  • dost_mittar: GT#47: Yes, we do and... Government Wins Manmohan Singh
  • guru: Ahmed, We had come to... Dhokha and Being a
  • sattar2: tahir bhai (re #408),... Of Medical Students, Passports
  • guru: Re: # 283 "After... Dhokha and Being a
  • mohar11: looks like Guru kicked... Dhokha and Being a
  • guru: Ahmed, Mind also this the... Dhokha and Being a

THEMES

  • Pakistan's Struggle for Democracy
  • The Indian Story
  • Indo-Pak Relations
  • Personal Narratives
  • Religion Today
  • War on Terror
  • Role of Media
  • Call for Social Change
  • Hold Them Accountable
  • Environment and Us
  • Way of Life
more »

Top 5 Articles This Week

  • Popular
  • Dhokha and Being a Muslim in India
  • Why is Karachi Turning Into a Sell-Out?
  • Time for Musharraf to Quit
  • Government Wins Manmohan Singh Loses
  • Fields Of Joy
  • Featured
  • There are a Lot of Monkeys
  • White Charade
  • Words of a Woman
  • FOX News and the Smelly Shoes
  • Dilemmas of Creative Children
  • 10 Years Ago
  • Your Rusted Knight
  • The Overlooked Problem of Pakistani Racism.
  • The Highway of Death
  • Women’s Rights in Pakistan
  • The Bulletin Board of a Believer

Write on Chowk Interact Guidelines Privacy policy Terms Contact

Copyright © 1997 - 2008 chowk.com. All Rights Reserved
Reproduction of material on any www.chowk.com pages without prior written permissions is strictly prohibited