Moeed Pirzada March 28, 2008
#483 Posted by CreateAlpha on April 3, 2008 12:36:00 pm
ajeya, whether kaal is chanakya incarnated or he is a fundo muslim is irrelevant to me. What is relevant is that he started off with equating "unversal truth" with "faith"....nothing he can say after that actually has any value other than to placate the fears of jihadis with his musings of "non-muslims (hindus althought I might be wrong, but on sundays I am right after I watch dancing with the stars) cannot understand muslims (those muslims who are not other muslims but muslims as definied by muslims)" :-)
#482 Posted by tahmed32 on April 3, 2008 12:21:32 pm
#481 ajeya: "Why are Paki Muslims boneheaded? Because they believe in "democracy" in an Islamic country."
Oh no. I must be smart and realize that we are doomed to have a dictatorship in Pakistan. Hindus like you are so clever!!
Oh no. I must be smart and realize that we are doomed to have a dictatorship in Pakistan. Hindus like you are so clever!!
#481 Posted by ajeya on April 3, 2008 12:10:06 pm
#455 CreateAlpha
You have to understand one thing about Kaalchakra/Ekalavya. He first looks up the definition for "communal" on www.dictionary.com:
com·mu·nal
Pronunciation Key - Show Spelled Pronunciation[kuh-myoon-l, kom-yuh-nl] Pronunciation Key - Show IPA Pronunciation
–adjective
1. used or shared in common by everyone in a group: a communal jug of wine.
2. of, by, or belonging to the people of a community; shared or participated in by the public: communal land; Building the playground was a communal project.
3. pertaining to a commune or a community: communal life.
4. engaged in by or involving two or more communities: communal conflict.
He has picked definition number 4 for his purpose. His point is that in Pakistan, Hindus have been virtually eliminated, so the question of "two or more communities" or communalism, doesn't arise. In India, with a Hindu majority, because minorities are thriving, therefore there is the question of "two or more communities" or communalism.
The boneheaded(see note at the end) Pakis don't see realize this. They are happy to see what they percieve as Hindu-bashing. Hindus on this forum are incensed and keep asking him for a justification. And Kaalchakra/Ekalavya simply sits back and enjoys the whole thing. It validates his belief that, although a "low-caste" hindu, he can hang in there with the "upper-caste" hindus, and even fool them with his "intellectual" double entrendes. This has led to some, like Alephnull, to declare him a "supreme teacher" or the "great master" who keeps posing zen-like questions to all who seek knowledge from "kaalchakra".
The whole thing is very impressive. Except, when pursued by some incensed Paki who has a rare moment of clarity and starts breathing down his neck. That's when Kaalchakra "compromises", and fully agrees with the Paki. To not do so would mean he would be deprived of his favorite pastime. So he does a "Advani praising Jinnah in Pakiland" impersonation for a few posts, and then comes back another day to resume his hobby.
N.B. Why are Paki Muslims boneheaded? Because they believe in "democracy" in an Islamic country.
You have to understand one thing about Kaalchakra/Ekalavya. He first looks up the definition for "communal" on www.dictionary.com:
com·mu·nal
Pronunciation Key - Show Spelled Pronunciation[kuh-myoon-l, kom-yuh-nl] Pronunciation Key - Show IPA Pronunciation
–adjective
1. used or shared in common by everyone in a group: a communal jug of wine.
2. of, by, or belonging to the people of a community; shared or participated in by the public: communal land; Building the playground was a communal project.
3. pertaining to a commune or a community: communal life.
4. engaged in by or involving two or more communities: communal conflict.
He has picked definition number 4 for his purpose. His point is that in Pakistan, Hindus have been virtually eliminated, so the question of "two or more communities" or communalism, doesn't arise. In India, with a Hindu majority, because minorities are thriving, therefore there is the question of "two or more communities" or communalism.
The boneheaded(see note at the end) Pakis don't see realize this. They are happy to see what they percieve as Hindu-bashing. Hindus on this forum are incensed and keep asking him for a justification. And Kaalchakra/Ekalavya simply sits back and enjoys the whole thing. It validates his belief that, although a "low-caste" hindu, he can hang in there with the "upper-caste" hindus, and even fool them with his "intellectual" double entrendes. This has led to some, like Alephnull, to declare him a "supreme teacher" or the "great master" who keeps posing zen-like questions to all who seek knowledge from "kaalchakra".
The whole thing is very impressive. Except, when pursued by some incensed Paki who has a rare moment of clarity and starts breathing down his neck. That's when Kaalchakra "compromises", and fully agrees with the Paki. To not do so would mean he would be deprived of his favorite pastime. So he does a "Advani praising Jinnah in Pakiland" impersonation for a few posts, and then comes back another day to resume his hobby.
N.B. Why are Paki Muslims boneheaded? Because they believe in "democracy" in an Islamic country.
#480 Posted by anil on April 3, 2008 11:39:59 am
Re: # 476
Guruji:
"...BTW if I were u once i know the victim I will personally meet the victim in the hospital and pay his hospital bill. Did u do that for the fellow Indian?..."
A twit will remain a twit, but I have done far far more than meet and pay. You are the people who start the fire? Would you let your hands be chopped off, and then have someone come and visit you in the hospital and pay your bill? Don't you realize that it is all after the fact?
You cannot be that ignorant, please stop this nonsense. I have now realized that my posts are way beyond you.
Guruji:
"...BTW if I were u once i know the victim I will personally meet the victim in the hospital and pay his hospital bill. Did u do that for the fellow Indian?..."
A twit will remain a twit, but I have done far far more than meet and pay. You are the people who start the fire? Would you let your hands be chopped off, and then have someone come and visit you in the hospital and pay your bill? Don't you realize that it is all after the fact?
You cannot be that ignorant, please stop this nonsense. I have now realized that my posts are way beyond you.
#479 Posted by akcheema on April 3, 2008 11:37:07 am
Re: (Eklavya No 452) "Chalta thinks there is no value in religion...."
He is not the only one Kaal. The only option is to completely discredit religious mythology, repeatedly, at every forum possible.
I for one can stand extremists better; with them, one knows where one stands and knows exactly where and who the enemy is. It is these (to quote a favourite writer) "namby pamby, weak tea" multiculturalist and "religion for personal relationship with some deity" crap I can't stand!
These are exactly the individuals that would be ultimately responsible for the survival of this mindset. A good example would be the 'old' Soviet block Central Asia; majority (if not all) of these were 'non-believing' muslims until recently. We are already seeing a resurgence of militancy in the name of Islam there in small pockets. Same in Turkey.
Unfortunately, it is for the rationalists to discredit these mythologies at every opportunity and 'prevent' its penetration into the next generation. Who is to say if I bring my children up as 'socio-cultural' muslims, either them or the generation after won't suddenly 're-interpret' this non-sense in its very original, "exactly how 'God' intended" form!
He is not the only one Kaal. The only option is to completely discredit religious mythology, repeatedly, at every forum possible.
I for one can stand extremists better; with them, one knows where one stands and knows exactly where and who the enemy is. It is these (to quote a favourite writer) "namby pamby, weak tea" multiculturalist and "religion for personal relationship with some deity" crap I can't stand!
These are exactly the individuals that would be ultimately responsible for the survival of this mindset. A good example would be the 'old' Soviet block Central Asia; majority (if not all) of these were 'non-believing' muslims until recently. We are already seeing a resurgence of militancy in the name of Islam there in small pockets. Same in Turkey.
Unfortunately, it is for the rationalists to discredit these mythologies at every opportunity and 'prevent' its penetration into the next generation. Who is to say if I bring my children up as 'socio-cultural' muslims, either them or the generation after won't suddenly 're-interpret' this non-sense in its very original, "exactly how 'God' intended" form!
#478 Posted by guru on April 3, 2008 11:19:05 am
Re: # 472:
"
The beauty is in pluralism and co-existence. Neither will dominate the other. Understand the forces that are shaping Today's India and be part of it. You are fortunate to be part of this India.
"
Dharmic people are inherently pluralistic and not just co-existed but celebrated diversity. Economic development is the only salvation. For that Indians should stop visiting this chowk. Good Bye!
BTW who is financing this website?
"
The beauty is in pluralism and co-existence. Neither will dominate the other. Understand the forces that are shaping Today's India and be part of it. You are fortunate to be part of this India.
"
Dharmic people are inherently pluralistic and not just co-existed but celebrated diversity. Economic development is the only salvation. For that Indians should stop visiting this chowk. Good Bye!
BTW who is financing this website?
#477 Posted by Salim_Chauhan on April 3, 2008 11:12:36 am
Anil Bhai and Guru Sahib,
Excuse me, gentlemen, but does the 5 number bus stop here?
Excuse me, gentlemen, but does the 5 number bus stop here?
#476 Posted by guru on April 3, 2008 11:08:24 am
Re: # 474:
I am talking about Thakres of 92-93. I do not read news papers. So what u are talking about I do not know.
BTW if I were u once i know the victim I will personally meet the victim in the hospital and pay his hospital bill. Did u do that for the fellow Indian? Stop crocodile tears and making others feel guilty. I know personally Raj from 96 and Balasaheb from 81. More close to Balasaheb.
Are u a SAJA guy?
I am talking about Thakres of 92-93. I do not read news papers. So what u are talking about I do not know.
BTW if I were u once i know the victim I will personally meet the victim in the hospital and pay his hospital bill. Did u do that for the fellow Indian? Stop crocodile tears and making others feel guilty. I know personally Raj from 96 and Balasaheb from 81. More close to Balasaheb.
Are u a SAJA guy?
#475 Posted by guru on April 3, 2008 10:59:22 am
Re: # 472:
Anil Elderly Coconut,
Elderly NRI are very hard coconuts. Western garbage seeped into their DNA.
"
secularism being the biggest reactionary force, and useless.
"
Elaborate which one was action? which one was reaction? what do u mean by useless and to whom?
To me Abrahmic religions and the west use religion for imperialism. Where the numbers are not favorable they create minoritism in the name of secularism so that they can sow divisions. Their religions are less spiritual and but more political.
For me the actions were Asuric/Rakshasi ones by Abrahmic folks.
Thakres are belated reactions to them.
Who is financing this site?
Anil Elderly Coconut,
Elderly NRI are very hard coconuts. Western garbage seeped into their DNA.
"
secularism being the biggest reactionary force, and useless.
"
Elaborate which one was action? which one was reaction? what do u mean by useless and to whom?
To me Abrahmic religions and the west use religion for imperialism. Where the numbers are not favorable they create minoritism in the name of secularism so that they can sow divisions. Their religions are less spiritual and but more political.
For me the actions were Asuric/Rakshasi ones by Abrahmic folks.
Thakres are belated reactions to them.
Who is financing this site?
#474 Posted by anil on April 3, 2008 10:48:36 am
Re: # 473
Guruji:
"...Raj has guts what about u? U cannot stop the aggressor and cannot redress the victim...."
If you call that cowardly act as guts. Shame on you. Ten goons taking on one innocent eeking out a living and chopping his hands is criminal act.
Please do not insult the mind that you have with such utterances.
Guruji:
"...Raj has guts what about u? U cannot stop the aggressor and cannot redress the victim...."
If you call that cowardly act as guts. Shame on you. Ten goons taking on one innocent eeking out a living and chopping his hands is criminal act.
Please do not insult the mind that you have with such utterances.
#473 Posted by guru on April 3, 2008 10:43:35 am
Re: # 468:
"
It is good to know India is jelling. I hope it is not jelling in the way of Raj Thackrey and Co. Your fear and biases do as much, even more disservice to Today's India then those attacks at Sankat Mochan. That should not be Today's India, it is all hate, fear and anger.
"
Raj has guts what about u? U cannot stop the aggressor and cannot redress the victim.
If the Godhra Muslim culprits were promptly hung and their uncles and Mamus were hung by their balls for a day or two then larger number of innocent Muslims would not have lost their lives else where. For the good of all minorit-ism which is being practiced in the name of secularism has served no one.
BTW are u SAJA journalist?
"
It is good to know India is jelling. I hope it is not jelling in the way of Raj Thackrey and Co. Your fear and biases do as much, even more disservice to Today's India then those attacks at Sankat Mochan. That should not be Today's India, it is all hate, fear and anger.
"
Raj has guts what about u? U cannot stop the aggressor and cannot redress the victim.
If the Godhra Muslim culprits were promptly hung and their uncles and Mamus were hung by their balls for a day or two then larger number of innocent Muslims would not have lost their lives else where. For the good of all minorit-ism which is being practiced in the name of secularism has served no one.
BTW are u SAJA journalist?
#472 Posted by anil on April 3, 2008 10:41:51 am
Re: # 469
Guruji:
"..inherently secular..."
Please read below what I wrote about secularism being the biggest reactionary force, and useless.
There is no need to compare Dharmic or Abrahmic. Such comparisons are useless. The beauty is in pluralism and co-existence. Neither will dominate the other. Understand the forces that are shaping Today's India and be part of it. You are fortunate to be part of this India.
Guruji:
"..inherently secular..."
Please read below what I wrote about secularism being the biggest reactionary force, and useless.
There is no need to compare Dharmic or Abrahmic. Such comparisons are useless. The beauty is in pluralism and co-existence. Neither will dominate the other. Understand the forces that are shaping Today's India and be part of it. You are fortunate to be part of this India.
#471 Posted by Eklavya on April 3, 2008 10:37:18 am
"If you are getting paid...."
Guru bhai, PLEASE, you perhaps are unaware but you are addressing a very respected elder of the site (even if this is a virtual world).
Sometimes, we can just listen, right? Let me reassure you anilji only means us all well.
Guru bhai, PLEASE, you perhaps are unaware but you are addressing a very respected elder of the site (even if this is a virtual world).
Sometimes, we can just listen, right? Let me reassure you anilji only means us all well.
#470 Posted by rf786 on April 3, 2008 10:36:59 am
Re: # 352
hamidm2
Isolating Mqm is part of NS policy to marginalize Musharraf, it has worked in the short term, but is going to backfire in the longer run.
Credit must be given to Zardari for showing political maturity by extending the alliance which will include Mqm. This reconciliatory policy should be all pervasive and also incorporate the Q-League members, this does not mean that they become part of the Govt but simply the "process".
Sheikh Rasheed, Javed Hashmi are seasoned politicians, we should have more of them.
hamidm2
Isolating Mqm is part of NS policy to marginalize Musharraf, it has worked in the short term, but is going to backfire in the longer run.
Credit must be given to Zardari for showing political maturity by extending the alliance which will include Mqm. This reconciliatory policy should be all pervasive and also incorporate the Q-League members, this does not mean that they become part of the Govt but simply the "process".
Sheikh Rasheed, Javed Hashmi are seasoned politicians, we should have more of them.
#469 Posted by guru on April 3, 2008 10:30:14 am
Re: # 465
"
I listed your quotes for you and others to see and make your mind.
"
That is the problem with words and quotes out of context. If you are getting paid to post here then you are doing a disservice to your master. By doing equal-equal between chalk and cheese, you are definitely screwing yourself with the chalk.
If I say Dharmic folks are inherently secular and Abrahmic religion folks as imperialists, is that bias? Did Dharmic folks attack others for the sake of their faith and exploited them with dhimmi stuff?
Who is financing this site?
"
I listed your quotes for you and others to see and make your mind.
"
That is the problem with words and quotes out of context. If you are getting paid to post here then you are doing a disservice to your master. By doing equal-equal between chalk and cheese, you are definitely screwing yourself with the chalk.
If I say Dharmic folks are inherently secular and Abrahmic religion folks as imperialists, is that bias? Did Dharmic folks attack others for the sake of their faith and exploited them with dhimmi stuff?
Who is financing this site?
#468 Posted by anil on April 3, 2008 10:28:21 am
Re: # 466
Guruji:
It is good to know India is jelling. I hope it is not jelling in the way of Raj Thackrey and Co. Your fear and biases do as much, even more disservice to Today's India then those attacks at Sankat Mochan. That should not be Today's India, it is all hate, fear and anger.
Guruji:
It is good to know India is jelling. I hope it is not jelling in the way of Raj Thackrey and Co. Your fear and biases do as much, even more disservice to Today's India then those attacks at Sankat Mochan. That should not be Today's India, it is all hate, fear and anger.
Interact Index
Latest Interacts
- nb: And how ridiculous to... Rape Survivor Families Struggle
- nb: Parthaab, you remind me... Rape Survivor Families Struggle
- jayp: Re: # 43 sharmeen, What are... ‘Dustbin of history’ or
- jayp: Re: # 19 tahmed, Paki civil... Rape Survivor Families Struggle
- nb: I never knew until... Terrorism Accused: Is Legal
- _arjun30: heh... ‘Pakistan loses $1.5bn due... ‘Dustbin of history’ or
- _arjun30: #64 Posted by... Terrorism Accused: Is Legal
- laddu: The more Islamist thinking... Terrorism Accused: Is Legal








reply to this interact
write a new interact
add to favorites
flag objectionable content