Aamir - A Film Review

arjun#34:

Different places, different factors. In India, it was triggered by Ayodhya, etc. Same in Palestine. But in UK and Europe, it is a combination of the sense of injustice fuelled by the concept of Umma.

“Between 1951 and 2000 jews won 32% of the noble prize for medicine.

For physics 32%

For economics 39%

For science 29%

This despite many of our best and brightest intellects dying in the gas chambers�

This begs the question if they were so persecuted, how come they achieved so much, this should dispel the myth of persecution once and for all, because they dominate Hollywood and western media, they have mastered the art of playing the sympathy card.

#33 Posted by dost_mittar on July 8, 2008 11:00:02 am

Good..we've made some progress...we've moved on from the injustices are the prime motivator to religious indoctrination is the prime motivation..

arjun:

you are confusing me with someone else; I did not say that islamic jihad is unrelated to religious beliefs.

arjun:

you are confusing me with someone else; I did not say that islamic jihad is unrelated to religious beliefs.

mohar,

I am all about love and harmony my friend, you seem to be hell bent on hatred.

the only one you end up hurting is yourself. :(

#21 Posted by dost_mittar on July 8, 2008 7:44:25 am


Yes, militancy in Kashmir


Oh..so you do admit there was militancy before babri..and jihadis were blowing up shit before america invaded iraq..

what about the brit-paki subway bombers..what excuse do you have for them...or the 9/11 saudis?

truth:

These are all allegations. In any case, let us return to the film, if we can.

hint: people who lost the detonator evidences provided by India to show involvement of Pakistan in 1993 mumbai bombing were also behind bhinderwale.

"
As for the Air India bombings, the perpetrators were saved from punishment by the bungling by the Canadian security agents and the silencing, including the killing, of anyone in the community who dared to testify against them."

hint: people who lost the detonator evidences provided by India to show involvement of Pakistan were behind bhinderwale.

railway strike in 74 was also by the same folks.

source for funding for some chauhan dude and bhindranwale is also same.

india had to pay for having friendship treaty with USSR.

Punjab problem is externally induced from the word go.

truth100#18;

Saudi funding has certainly contributed to the expansion of puritanical islam at the expense of the more moderate sufi islam in India, but is not directly responsible for muslim alienation in India.

As for the Air India bombings, the perpetrators were saved from punishment by the bungling by the Canadian security agents and the silencing, including the killing, of anyone in the community who dared to testify against them. Nothing to do with Pakistan or Muslims; in fact, a Muslim journalist has been the most persistent in investigating the crime.

How sad is this? Aslam is a Brit-pakistani and he thinks there was no persecution of Jews in pre-Nazi Western Europe?
How can we hope for madarsa educated children when the British state system produces this?

Re: # 18 dost,

islamic millitancy was going to happen in india anyway because of saudi funding. punjab millitancy was because of pakistan. who do you think is protecting the Air India plane bombers in Canada? why the ignitors of bombs in 93 were made in US and were shipped from pakiland?

Re: # 20

Sometimes I think Kaal is right after all - hanoods are giving up too much space to these people - who in turn contribute nothing and actually do more harm than any good to the overall development of india and its society...

Really sad...

Re: # 8 hoori
[..it is another way to show the "bad muslims" ain't it :)..]

What's wrong with that?... if you want, you can go ahead make a movie to show bad hanoods ... although that would be pointless, you have "bad hanoods" in your textbooks...

I mean you muslims literally teach your kids how bad hanoods are... this is just a movie and yet you are complaining... man, you pakis are such idiots...

arjun#19:

Yes, militancy in Kashmir was also due to the constant rigging of the electoral process in that state by the central government.
As for militancy in the Muslim world in general, that is not identical to the Indian situation.