Ather Naqvi March 2, 2009
#193 Posted by majumdar on March 4, 2009 10:22:15 pm
Posting on the behalf of Masadi sb who continues to remain in illegal detention by chowk.
Maj writes "Why shud RAW retaliate for an operation that was carried out by itself (as per you guys).
Simple answer to escalate what they wanted to achieve from Bombay but which increasingly fizzled out. The question that needs to be asked is who stands to gain from these attacks and why now. Answering both questions leads to the US/India alliance in Afghanistan to destabilize Pakistan and pave the way for Martial Law there, before the U.S' upcoming plans for Iran. The first stage of this destabilization began with the Bombay attacks that were similar to these ones in methodology of street firefight which has not occurred before in the various suicide blast incidents in Pakistan. This was a "new" method, and one "imported" from Bombay.
Any local group seeking to gain support by attacking Pakistani cricket shoots themselves in the foot. This is not the work of local groups. An attack on Pakistani cricket has greater symbolic shock value than the intended bloodshed, especially for India who wants to paint Pakistan a terrorist state and isolate it internationally. Why the Sri Lankan team was chosen also points to India in my opinion. These attacks Mumbai and Lahore, point to the unholy alliance between the CIA/India and their common cause viz-a-viz Afghanistan (where India is deeply involved in various projects) to the destabilization of Pakistan, which has become for the U.S., the "central front" on the War on Terrorism, much like Iraq was constructed before the 2003 war.
TNITC masadi
Regards
Maj writes "Why shud RAW retaliate for an operation that was carried out by itself (as per you guys).
Simple answer to escalate what they wanted to achieve from Bombay but which increasingly fizzled out. The question that needs to be asked is who stands to gain from these attacks and why now. Answering both questions leads to the US/India alliance in Afghanistan to destabilize Pakistan and pave the way for Martial Law there, before the U.S' upcoming plans for Iran. The first stage of this destabilization began with the Bombay attacks that were similar to these ones in methodology of street firefight which has not occurred before in the various suicide blast incidents in Pakistan. This was a "new" method, and one "imported" from Bombay.
Any local group seeking to gain support by attacking Pakistani cricket shoots themselves in the foot. This is not the work of local groups. An attack on Pakistani cricket has greater symbolic shock value than the intended bloodshed, especially for India who wants to paint Pakistan a terrorist state and isolate it internationally. Why the Sri Lankan team was chosen also points to India in my opinion. These attacks Mumbai and Lahore, point to the unholy alliance between the CIA/India and their common cause viz-a-viz Afghanistan (where India is deeply involved in various projects) to the destabilization of Pakistan, which has become for the U.S., the "central front" on the War on Terrorism, much like Iraq was constructed before the 2003 war.
TNITC masadi
Regards
#192 Posted by jayp on March 4, 2009 10:11:52 pm
There is only one element that could point to a RAW role in the attack. The rocket fired at the bus missed the target, and it cannot happen if it were fired by an ISI trained jihadi.
#191 Posted by jayp on March 4, 2009 10:04:46 pm
Pleading for sense of proportion
////////////////
When paki jihadis killed a two hundred in mumbai, the paki journalists and others on chowk asked a very relevant question, why india is making such a big issue, it is not a big issue here in pakistan, becasue several thousands die each month in jihadic killings.
Now in the case of srilankan attack, no cricketer died..what is the big deal.
It is time that the pakis go back and watch a few public beheadings in swat, see a few more music stores blown up. I do hope that the jihadi council will rule that cricket is haram. Then there will be not even a whimper from the tahmeds of chowk. All earlier cricketers will be like abdus salam, no one will talk about them.
////////////////
When paki jihadis killed a two hundred in mumbai, the paki journalists and others on chowk asked a very relevant question, why india is making such a big issue, it is not a big issue here in pakistan, becasue several thousands die each month in jihadic killings.
Now in the case of srilankan attack, no cricketer died..what is the big deal.
It is time that the pakis go back and watch a few public beheadings in swat, see a few more music stores blown up. I do hope that the jihadi council will rule that cricket is haram. Then there will be not even a whimper from the tahmeds of chowk. All earlier cricketers will be like abdus salam, no one will talk about them.
#190 Posted by ajeya on March 4, 2009 9:56:46 pm
#179 tahmed32
[hamidm: namaz doesnt cause terrorism. lawlessness does.
granted traditional "islam" in pakistan is a bogus religion, a tit-for-tat deal with Allah. i.e. I say my prayers, you - Allah - watch out for me; I circle around in mecca, you throw away all my traffic tickets. And it goes downhill from there - tasbih, pir and so forth.]
It is truly strange, is it not, that nobody has caught up to this "core message" of Islam in 1400 years? And if the muslim public have not caught on to this revolutionary "There is but one God, Fullstop" message in 1400 years, and have always been jihadic and barbaric, then what hope is there that they will any time in the future? I don't think Tahmed's one-liner koran is going to appeal to the masses.
[but that is no worse than any other religion, and a hell of a lot better than naked men running around exposing themselves as they do in india.]
No, idiot. You have to take off your jihadic hat and start thinking like a human being. Actually ellora took the words out of my mouth. The naked sadhus might appeal less to your or Hamid's aesthetic sense than white nudists, but the important point is that they are harmless, they are not trying to convert you or kill you, unlike your fellow journeymen and co-students of the same textbook - the mullas.
[hamidm: namaz doesnt cause terrorism. lawlessness does.
granted traditional "islam" in pakistan is a bogus religion, a tit-for-tat deal with Allah. i.e. I say my prayers, you - Allah - watch out for me; I circle around in mecca, you throw away all my traffic tickets. And it goes downhill from there - tasbih, pir and so forth.]
It is truly strange, is it not, that nobody has caught up to this "core message" of Islam in 1400 years? And if the muslim public have not caught on to this revolutionary "There is but one God, Fullstop" message in 1400 years, and have always been jihadic and barbaric, then what hope is there that they will any time in the future? I don't think Tahmed's one-liner koran is going to appeal to the masses.
[but that is no worse than any other religion, and a hell of a lot better than naked men running around exposing themselves as they do in india.]
No, idiot. You have to take off your jihadic hat and start thinking like a human being. Actually ellora took the words out of my mouth. The naked sadhus might appeal less to your or Hamid's aesthetic sense than white nudists, but the important point is that they are harmless, they are not trying to convert you or kill you, unlike your fellow journeymen and co-students of the same textbook - the mullas.
#189 Posted by ellora on March 4, 2009 9:21:02 pm
"and a hell of a lot better than naked men running around exposing themselves as they do in india."
Those naked men don't behead/blow up guests. In that regard they are better than many devout people. Perhaps the first step to fighting terrorism is to get one's priorities straight.
Those naked men don't behead/blow up guests. In that regard they are better than many devout people. Perhaps the first step to fighting terrorism is to get one's priorities straight.
#188 Posted by nkg on March 4, 2009 9:02:24 pm
Re: # 187
Riaz...
http://www.foreignpolicy.com/images/fs2008/failed_states_ranking.j pg
May be little better now (within 5)....
beduinoid barbarian, your brothers who were involved in Mumbai incident, used un-armed civilians as shield. Mumbai is very crowded place. It is not very easy to handle situation like this, without sacrificing lives of large number of common people. Furhermore that area (Noriman point etc.) is at sea face and the threat perception was very low. Nobody has ever thought that jihadis will arrive through sea route ( none of islamic heroes and your national icons like ghaznavi, baboor, bin kashem etc...fought using sea route only. Who will imagine that Pakis will deviate from their national heroes) and reach close to two of the most crowded railway stations ( VT/CST and Churchgate)....
India being democracy, the ruling political party have to see that the number of human casualty is kept as low as possible. Otherwise, they will loose next election. The lesson from 1993 blasts was enough for Congress...
I think, you need to know a good democratic setup...
as beduine clone/musla your statement is quite prredictable. but then you know someother language than urdooo....some browing in internet is enough....
Nobody is claiming Mumbai and Lahore incidents are similar...apart from couple of police, nobody died in Lahore...
Can you make people believe a gang of 12/13 gunman failed to burst a single tyre of the bus or hurl a single granade properly under the vehicle, if they wanted to kill the players?
all this drama will not save your parents and relatives from Hellfire and other missile attacks from ISAF....
hamid...
so, these are very acute problems, that too only the non- muslas face?...
what about some positive agenda? like, if some one, keeps faith in arabic moon god and his last messanger, he will not suffer from any desease, he will not die, he will always be young etc... something on earth, not in arabic heaven....
Riaz...
http://www.foreignpolicy.com/images/fs2008/failed_states_ranking.j pg
May be little better now (within 5)....
beduinoid barbarian, your brothers who were involved in Mumbai incident, used un-armed civilians as shield. Mumbai is very crowded place. It is not very easy to handle situation like this, without sacrificing lives of large number of common people. Furhermore that area (Noriman point etc.) is at sea face and the threat perception was very low. Nobody has ever thought that jihadis will arrive through sea route ( none of islamic heroes and your national icons like ghaznavi, baboor, bin kashem etc...fought using sea route only. Who will imagine that Pakis will deviate from their national heroes) and reach close to two of the most crowded railway stations ( VT/CST and Churchgate)....
India being democracy, the ruling political party have to see that the number of human casualty is kept as low as possible. Otherwise, they will loose next election. The lesson from 1993 blasts was enough for Congress...
I think, you need to know a good democratic setup...
as beduine clone/musla your statement is quite prredictable. but then you know someother language than urdooo....some browing in internet is enough....
Nobody is claiming Mumbai and Lahore incidents are similar...apart from couple of police, nobody died in Lahore...
Can you make people believe a gang of 12/13 gunman failed to burst a single tyre of the bus or hurl a single granade properly under the vehicle, if they wanted to kill the players?
all this drama will not save your parents and relatives from Hellfire and other missile attacks from ISAF....
hamid...
so, these are very acute problems, that too only the non- muslas face?...
what about some positive agenda? like, if some one, keeps faith in arabic moon god and his last messanger, he will not suffer from any desease, he will not die, he will always be young etc... something on earth, not in arabic heaven....
#187 Posted by RiazHaq on March 4, 2009 8:28:35 pm
While it is tempting to compare Lahore with Mumbai superficially, it does not hold when you realize that Mumbai remained under siege for more than two days by less than a dozen attackers and the Indian security forces were rendered completely helpless. Although it was clearly a security lapse in Lahore, it bears very little resemblance to Mumbai. And stretching it to conclude that Pak is a failed state is just self-serving exaggeration by India’s Congress leaders and other Indians engaging in wishful thinking.
Riaz Haq, PakAlumni Worldwide
Riaz Haq, PakAlumni Worldwide
#186 Posted by hamidm2 on March 4, 2009 7:31:45 pm
Re: # 185
nkg,
..... repent, you infidel! ...... this is what the koran says will happen to you if you don't believe in al-lah as the one and only god and mohammad (pbuhahc) as his last messenger :
" Thou shalt betroth a wife, and another man shall lie with her: thou shalt build a house, and thou shalt not dwell therein: thou shalt plant a vineyard, and shalt not gather the grapes thereof.
Thine ox shall be slain before thine eyes, and thou shalt not eat thereof: thine ass shall be violently taken away from before thy face, and shall not be restored to thee: thy sheep shall be given unto thine enemies, and thou shalt have none to rescue them.
Thy sons and thy daughters shall be given unto another people, and thine eyes shall look, and fail with longing for them all the day long: and there shall be no might in thine hand.
The fruit of thy land, and all thy labors, shall a nation which thou knowest not eat up; and thou shalt be only oppressed and crushed alway:
so that thou shalt be mad for the sight of thine eyes which thou shalt see.
Allah shall smite thee in the knees, and in the legs, with a sore botch that cannot be healed, from the sole of thy foot unto the top of thy head.............."
.......... worried? scared? ...... so give up your idolatary and join the ranks of the true believers ...... you can still be saved
nkg,
..... repent, you infidel! ...... this is what the koran says will happen to you if you don't believe in al-lah as the one and only god and mohammad (pbuhahc) as his last messenger :
" Thou shalt betroth a wife, and another man shall lie with her: thou shalt build a house, and thou shalt not dwell therein: thou shalt plant a vineyard, and shalt not gather the grapes thereof.
Thine ox shall be slain before thine eyes, and thou shalt not eat thereof: thine ass shall be violently taken away from before thy face, and shall not be restored to thee: thy sheep shall be given unto thine enemies, and thou shalt have none to rescue them.
Thy sons and thy daughters shall be given unto another people, and thine eyes shall look, and fail with longing for them all the day long: and there shall be no might in thine hand.
The fruit of thy land, and all thy labors, shall a nation which thou knowest not eat up; and thou shalt be only oppressed and crushed alway:
so that thou shalt be mad for the sight of thine eyes which thou shalt see.
Allah shall smite thee in the knees, and in the legs, with a sore botch that cannot be healed, from the sole of thy foot unto the top of thy head.............."
.......... worried? scared? ...... so give up your idolatary and join the ranks of the true believers ...... you can still be saved
#185 Posted by nkg on March 4, 2009 6:39:41 pm
Re: # 180
tahemd...
whether you admit it or not, world knows this as "Islamic" barbarism/terrorism and the inspiration is KoRun etc....whatever way you may try to defend source of problem, the muulah's has not invented KoRun or verses for KoRun, which incites people to kill others in the name of god. India do not lack god fearing people. But then, that has not culminated bloodthirsty animals....
there is no dearth of countries on earth, which is ruled by military dictators (North Koreas was under military dictator for long time....). That has not made them barbaric animals....
Hamid,
whether you pray 5 times or 1 time, can you ignore the core message of islam and deviate from the deeds of Muhammed? Simply no...Anyhow keep trying your best to formulate special musla...
tahemd...
whether you admit it or not, world knows this as "Islamic" barbarism/terrorism and the inspiration is KoRun etc....whatever way you may try to defend source of problem, the muulah's has not invented KoRun or verses for KoRun, which incites people to kill others in the name of god. India do not lack god fearing people. But then, that has not culminated bloodthirsty animals....
there is no dearth of countries on earth, which is ruled by military dictators (North Koreas was under military dictator for long time....). That has not made them barbaric animals....
Hamid,
whether you pray 5 times or 1 time, can you ignore the core message of islam and deviate from the deeds of Muhammed? Simply no...Anyhow keep trying your best to formulate special musla...
#184 Posted by majumdar on March 4, 2009 6:38:12 pm
Riaz Haq sahib,
There has been a lot of discussion in India by former RAW officials to launch covert actions inside Pakistan after Mumbai.
Why shud RAW retaliate for an operation that was carried out by itself (as per you guys)
REgards
There has been a lot of discussion in India by former RAW officials to launch covert actions inside Pakistan after Mumbai.
Why shud RAW retaliate for an operation that was carried out by itself (as per you guys)
REgards
#183 Posted by anil on March 4, 2009 6:37:37 pm
Tahmed sahib:
I did not know what your objective was in your post to Hamidm sahib. By all means continue your slugfest. You by now know my views on religion. It does not bother me, and I do not bother it. There is a symbiotic relationship and I leave at that.
I did not know what your objective was in your post to Hamidm sahib. By all means continue your slugfest. You by now know my views on religion. It does not bother me, and I do not bother it. There is a symbiotic relationship and I leave at that.
#182 Posted by tahmed32 on March 4, 2009 6:27:56 pm
anil sahib: i would not mention hinduism - but given the ease with which your countrymen (lesser "insaan" than you) ridicule islam, i dont see any reason to be respectful of hinduism either. and i honestly do think that islam is a simpler religion (fewer stupid rituals) than most - hinduism and roman catholicism in particular.
#181 Posted by anil on March 4, 2009 6:15:57 pm
Re: # 179
Tahmed sahib:
"...but that is no worse than any other religion, and a hell of a lot better than naked men running around exposing themselves as they do in india..."
Why must you discuss your Islam with reference to other religion?
I am certain you have cave dweller version to Masadi version to yours to Hamidm version. Believer me there is enough for you make your points and counter points.
This urge to discuss Islam seems to me reflects an unnecessary complex. Now please don't take this as an expression of interest to criticize you or your religion. It is an observation. I could not care, if you had said seven times around Shiva Lingham, or rat worshipping temple. They both have rituals which some like me could not care less.
Tahmed sahib:
"...but that is no worse than any other religion, and a hell of a lot better than naked men running around exposing themselves as they do in india..."
Why must you discuss your Islam with reference to other religion?
I am certain you have cave dweller version to Masadi version to yours to Hamidm version. Believer me there is enough for you make your points and counter points.
This urge to discuss Islam seems to me reflects an unnecessary complex. Now please don't take this as an expression of interest to criticize you or your religion. It is an observation. I could not care, if you had said seven times around Shiva Lingham, or rat worshipping temple. They both have rituals which some like me could not care less.
#180 Posted by tahmed32 on March 4, 2009 6:11:47 pm
although i agree mosques should be abolished in pakistan - they are the mullahs license to impose himself through the loudspeaker on the community in most cases, and terrorist hideouts (as in lal masjid) at worst.
but these terrorists were not created by the mosque - they were created by duds like hamid gul. the mosque merely nurtured them.
but these terrorists were not created by the mosque - they were created by duds like hamid gul. the mosque merely nurtured them.
#179 Posted by tahmed32 on March 4, 2009 6:03:46 pm
hamidm: namaz doesnt cause terrorism. lawlessness does.
granted traditional "islam" in pakistan is a bogus religion, a tit-for-tat deal with Allah. i.e. I say my prayers, you - Allah - watch out for me; I circle around in mecca, you throw away all my traffic tickets. And it goes downhill from there - tasbih, pir and so forth. but that is no worse than any other religion, and a hell of a lot better than naked men running around exposing themselves as they do in india.
trouble in pakistan is, as i keep saying, is your (and mine) military cousins. those duds sowed the seed that Pakistan is now reaping.
granted traditional "islam" in pakistan is a bogus religion, a tit-for-tat deal with Allah. i.e. I say my prayers, you - Allah - watch out for me; I circle around in mecca, you throw away all my traffic tickets. And it goes downhill from there - tasbih, pir and so forth. but that is no worse than any other religion, and a hell of a lot better than naked men running around exposing themselves as they do in india.
trouble in pakistan is, as i keep saying, is your (and mine) military cousins. those duds sowed the seed that Pakistan is now reaping.
#178 Posted by nkg on March 4, 2009 5:52:13 pm
Re: # 172
PM...
Anti-state actors are fine, but why they will collaborate with India? Can Naxalites in central India be used by Paki jihadi heroes like Hamid Gul?
Ans: No. You need muslas in India to assist the upper management in Pakistan and top management in Saudi arabia of the Jihadi/Islamic Organisation...
PM...
Anti-state actors are fine, but why they will collaborate with India? Can Naxalites in central India be used by Paki jihadi heroes like Hamid Gul?
Ans: No. You need muslas in India to assist the upper management in Pakistan and top management in Saudi arabia of the Jihadi/Islamic Organisation...
Interact Index
Latest Interacts
- majumdar: Harishbhai, ....However, please take enough... The Jehadi Frankenstein
- harish_hyd: ...install a friendly government... The Jehadi Frankenstein
- harish_hyd: #19 by Goldfinger harish...indeed the... The Jehadi Frankenstein
- jayp: Adnan, There can be no... Morality of Lawyers' Movement
- harish_hyd: Karzai is a crony... Crowning of a Crony
- jayp: Some one is listening I... I Want Jinnah's Pakistan
- SureshM: Re: # 19 From... The Jehadi Frankenstein
- Goldfinger: Re: # 5 Riaz sb...yes... NRO Is Just a








reply to this interact
write a new interact
add to favorites
flag objectionable content