Shandana Minhas September 16, 1998
#21 Posted by Shazad on December 2, 1998 3:31:19 pm
Its always great to read something so angrily refreshing-tends to break the monotony.
#19 Posted by Anita Zaidi on September 19, 1998 10:20:49 am
Shandy, if I may call you that - your honesty is as refreshing, as your neologisms fascinating.
Here`s to hoping you find some true women friends.
Cheers,
Anita
Here`s to hoping you find some true women friends.
Cheers,
Anita
#18 Posted by slink on September 18, 1998 8:46:44 pm
re anita: you have hit the proverbial nail on the head (infact at this very minute it`s probably reeling around cursing you :). this poem was written was at a time when i was floating through life, rudderless and practically friendless, listening to lots of people (family and otherwise) tell me how i was wasting my time and energy doing nothing. the female thing is because in my experience women here tend to be more critical of other womens shortcomings. men tend to take you for what you are, women always judge you. a gross generalization i know, but like i said, that has been my experience.
i`ve actually just realized that most of my pieces tend to seem very anti-woman,even when i dont consciously mean them to be. call it catharsis if you will :) i`ve had to listen to a lot of female bitching and do the `i dont care what you say` thing, but i guess it marked me more deeply than i let on at the time :)
re zehra: i love rhyme. this was actually one of the first poems i wrote, rhyming or otherwise, and it continues to be one of my favourites. i recite it in the shower as often as i can.
thank you all for bothering to register your reaction
shandana
i`ve actually just realized that most of my pieces tend to seem very anti-woman,even when i dont consciously mean them to be. call it catharsis if you will :) i`ve had to listen to a lot of female bitching and do the `i dont care what you say` thing, but i guess it marked me more deeply than i let on at the time :)
re zehra: i love rhyme. this was actually one of the first poems i wrote, rhyming or otherwise, and it continues to be one of my favourites. i recite it in the shower as often as i can.
thank you all for bothering to register your reaction
shandana
#17 Posted by Anita Zaidi on September 18, 1998 11:05:38 am
Shandana,
I really enjoy your stuff. Can`t help asking though - why does this piece remind me of ``the other woman``. There is something anti-woman here, although the cat is identified as an ``it``, you go on to refer to it as a bitc`h at the end, so you must have a female creature in mind - the poem seems to be a parable - an account of a betrayed friendship perhaps, or a relationship with a close relative that is perceived as too intrusive, even destructive. To me that comes across brutally. It is an emotive read.
Keep writing!
Anita
I really enjoy your stuff. Can`t help asking though - why does this piece remind me of ``the other woman``. There is something anti-woman here, although the cat is identified as an ``it``, you go on to refer to it as a bitc`h at the end, so you must have a female creature in mind - the poem seems to be a parable - an account of a betrayed friendship perhaps, or a relationship with a close relative that is perceived as too intrusive, even destructive. To me that comes across brutally. It is an emotive read.
Keep writing!
Anita
#16 Posted by Zehra on September 18, 1998 7:54:16 am
In the blackness that was drowning me at reading your words of not writing material like this, i almost forgot, well i DID forget, to share my reaction with you. i was surprised to see a ``rhyming poem`` and was so pleased after i read it. ryhming strikes me as chessy at times but you made it flow in this wonderful hey diddle diddle way. i loved it :) it made me feel happy, cheery and is sure as hell gonna help in the next four and half hours left to work :))
can i be in your shagirdi plz?
:P
thank you.
z.rizvi.
can i be in your shagirdi plz?
:P
thank you.
z.rizvi.
#15 Posted by Zehra on September 18, 1998 7:54:16 am
re: slink
what do you mean chastened and promising to never write non serious stuff again?
NOoooooooooooooooo, you CANT do that! noooooooooooooooooo...
what will become of us?
Z. (almost dead from grief) Rizvi.
what do you mean chastened and promising to never write non serious stuff again?
NOoooooooooooooooo, you CANT do that! noooooooooooooooooo...
what will become of us?
Z. (almost dead from grief) Rizvi.
#14 Posted by mastanah on September 18, 1998 7:54:16 am
as the last drops of feline life trickled from her veins, she looked through her velvet eyes in vain.
at shandy into whose room she had pranced, with the least disdain.
from hasty praise, she`ll now refrain.
and in her second, a silent well-wisher remain.
all the blood and the stain, worst was the pain.
she spoke and was misunderstood, or judged rather plain.
it was nice to see you, but you killed me --- till we meet again.
at shandy into whose room she had pranced, with the least disdain.
from hasty praise, she`ll now refrain.
and in her second, a silent well-wisher remain.
all the blood and the stain, worst was the pain.
she spoke and was misunderstood, or judged rather plain.
it was nice to see you, but you killed me --- till we meet again.
#13 Posted by Kafir on September 18, 1998 7:54:16 am
Dr. Seuss meets Edgar Allan Poe meets Henry Miller...
Meeoow!
Meeoow!
#12 Posted by RanaRansher on September 17, 1998 11:36:15 am
BRILLIANT !!
... draws appreciation from amazingly varied perspectives.
... draws appreciation from amazingly varied perspectives.
#11 Posted by slink on September 17, 1998 9:24:46 am
dear aspiring lizard..no it wasn`t the fag (or even the tequila). beach brewery (chotu if you`e reading this it`s a brewery in karachi) has this potent lemon and pineapple vodka..but i digress :) the point is,it`s very nice of you to blame those of my pieces you dont like on my being tun at the time but it`s simply not true. i was very very sober when i wrote that.
re temporal: thank you for pointing out the fact that there are lots of things in shwot that need to be pointed out so i can spell `em right
thanks anita, amin and co :))
shandana (suitably chastened and promising to never write anything non-serious again)) minhas
re temporal: thank you for pointing out the fact that there are lots of things in shwot that need to be pointed out so i can spell `em right
thanks anita, amin and co :))
shandana (suitably chastened and promising to never write anything non-serious again)) minhas
#10 Posted by Aliya on September 17, 1998 8:21:05 am
I am no poet, and know little about whats good poetry, but that was a fun fun fun thing to read.
Aliya
Aliya
#9 Posted by Ras Siddiqui on September 17, 1998 8:21:05 am
We know that you can write much better then
this. And that has nothing to do with the
ending. That ``fag`` or tequila was just much too potent.
Ras
(Aspiring Lizard)
#8 Posted by temporal on September 16, 1998 5:42:53 pm
Assumption: the typos are unintentional-- they mar and jar an otherwise good read. And the same effect if they are intentional.
regards,
regards,
#6 Posted by dL on September 16, 1998 5:42:53 pm
Thats some serious creativity
at least in how we see it
you might well be pouring forth
yourself
something about in the end we`re all dead
comes to mind !
i could almost visualize the
electrical impulses
darting
across neurons
good stuff
at least in how we see it
you might well be pouring forth
yourself
something about in the end we`re all dead
comes to mind !
i could almost visualize the
electrical impulses
darting
across neurons
good stuff
listing 1-16
1 2
Interact Index
Similar Articles
- They Will Seal The Case Sheets! Prashant Bhatt
- Ahmed Faraz (1931-2008) – The Romantic Rebel Zaki Rahman
- Muhammad Aslam Khan Khattak: A Man for All Seasons Zeejah
- Terrorism Accused: Is Legal Aid Justified? Shridhar Naik
- Losing the Battle, Losing the Faith Ehtisham Iqbal
US Elections 2008 Primaries
Latest Interacts
- majumdar: Kaal bhai, Now or Never... Muhammad Aslam Khan Khattak:
- nkg: Re: # 133 Special provision... Terrorism Accused: Is Legal
- majumdar: Nkg moshai, What is wrong... Terrorism Accused: Is Legal
- nkg: Re: # 128 Dinaric... RSS is... Terrorism Accused: Is Legal
- nkg: Re: # 120 HP... The core... Terrorism Accused: Is Legal
- nkg: Re: # 98 hamidm2... " what... ‘Dustbin of history’ or
- pinku: add to #133 Posted... ‘Dustbin of history’ or
- pinku: #127 Posted by tahmed32... ‘Dustbin of history’ or








reply to this interact
write a new interact
add to favorites
flag objectionable content