Faisal December 23, 2001
#17 Posted by FarzanaVersey on December 29, 2001 2:37:36 pm
Faisal:
Who told you that clarity and depth are mutually exclusive? One goes deeper precisely to get a clearer understanding of something. Being simplistic is not the pot of gold at the end of
the rainbow. Anyway, now your poem is out of your hands, and I shall probe it as much as I wish :)
It is possible that you were merely writing another version of ``row, row, row your boat``, but then you haven`t seen me deconstruct THAT one, have you????
Who told you that clarity and depth are mutually exclusive? One goes deeper precisely to get a clearer understanding of something. Being simplistic is not the pot of gold at the end of
the rainbow. Anyway, now your poem is out of your hands, and I shall probe it as much as I wish :)
It is possible that you were merely writing another version of ``row, row, row your boat``, but then you haven`t seen me deconstruct THAT one, have you????
#16 Posted by Faisals on December 26, 2001 11:48:31 pm
Thank you everyone for taking time to read this. Have a wonderful new year!
Faisal
Faisal
#15 Posted by Faisals on December 26, 2001 4:35:21 pm
Ras: Thanks for appreciating this poem. Some of the indentations were left during the submission process. I just emailed the poem to the editors again.
Kiran and Farzana: Thanks for taking this much interest. This is from a snapshot in memory and I was pondering on the displacement of being so I used this old anecdote...
I was thinking that the sky, the journey, the lake, intellect and more importantly a river is an abstraction and as they pour into a metaphor I tried to give them a place or conversely a sense of displacement by using ``brown skin`` instead of ``skin,`` and so forth. That would explain the manifestations of these labels throughout. However a lot of the form was lost because the indentations did not get printed (chowk staff will probably fix that).
``The sun above...`` is almost an afterthought to the narrator in the form of stream of consciousness. It`s place is not entirely elemental, as the river below and the sky all around, instead metaphorically a wiser presence that juxtaposes the narrator’s conclusion. This is something I picked up from Urdu poetry, especially N M Rashid. You take the age old characteristics of nature (falak, behr-e-zulmat etc) and humanize them.
I hope this answers your questions. It is really not a deep poem, so don`t read do much into it. I have struggled with clarity in all my poetry...
RSaxena: I couldn’t agree more :)
Cheers,
Faisal
Kiran and Farzana: Thanks for taking this much interest. This is from a snapshot in memory and I was pondering on the displacement of being so I used this old anecdote...
I was thinking that the sky, the journey, the lake, intellect and more importantly a river is an abstraction and as they pour into a metaphor I tried to give them a place or conversely a sense of displacement by using ``brown skin`` instead of ``skin,`` and so forth. That would explain the manifestations of these labels throughout. However a lot of the form was lost because the indentations did not get printed (chowk staff will probably fix that).
``The sun above...`` is almost an afterthought to the narrator in the form of stream of consciousness. It`s place is not entirely elemental, as the river below and the sky all around, instead metaphorically a wiser presence that juxtaposes the narrator’s conclusion. This is something I picked up from Urdu poetry, especially N M Rashid. You take the age old characteristics of nature (falak, behr-e-zulmat etc) and humanize them.
I hope this answers your questions. It is really not a deep poem, so don`t read do much into it. I have struggled with clarity in all my poetry...
RSaxena: I couldn’t agree more :)
Cheers,
Faisal
#12 Posted by Ras Siddiqui on December 25, 2001 12:24:16 pm
A Very Merry Christmas to all CHOWK readers.
Ras
#11 Posted by Kiran- on December 24, 2001 3:57:59 pm
Charming use of imagery Mr. Siddiqui. Enjoyed it. Have to agree with Farzana though, why ``Asian`` intellect?
Do interact.
Regards
Kiran
Do interact.
Regards
Kiran
#10 Posted by Kiran- on December 24, 2001 3:57:59 pm
Charming use of imagery Mr. Siddiqui. Enjoyed it. Have to agree with Farzana though, why ``Asian`` intellect?
Do interact.
Regards
Kiran
Do interact.
Regards
Kiran
#7 Posted by wasiq on December 24, 2001 2:41:34 am
Two men are on lake Austin
they`ve been in this Texas town for a while now
the boating and the water mix into their
converging diverging thought patterns
nicely done
they`ve been in this Texas town for a while now
the boating and the water mix into their
converging diverging thought patterns
nicely done
#5 Posted by FarzanaVersey on December 23, 2001 2:37:21 am
Faisal Siddiqui:
You are obviously a `seeker` and some of the imagery was quite palpable. However, I did not like the use of `Asian intellect`. Woner why you did it. I would also like to know why you have specifically italicised ``the sun above squints
and understands this reverence``...could anyone enlighten me? I can think of a few reasons, but I am at a loss regarding its place here all the same.
But `felt` the poem...
Farzana
You are obviously a `seeker` and some of the imagery was quite palpable. However, I did not like the use of `Asian intellect`. Woner why you did it. I would also like to know why you have specifically italicised ``the sun above squints
and understands this reverence``...could anyone enlighten me? I can think of a few reasons, but I am at a loss regarding its place here all the same.
But `felt` the poem...
Farzana
#3 Posted by Ras Siddiqui on December 22, 2001 1:39:48 pm
Welcome to CHOWK Faisal. It feels great to see another Siddiqui here.
This work is moving and full of imagination.
Ras
listing 1-16
1 2
Interact Index
Similar Articles
- The Indian Obama! Joe Athialy
- Cricket: Afridi is Our Future Shiraz Mahmood
- Thought for Food and Food for Thought Faysal Malik
- The Correct Turn Nadeem F Paracha
- Politics of PPP and Asif Zardari Ali Chishti
US Elections 2008 Primaries
Latest Interacts
- nb: And back to NFP's... The Correct Turn
- nb: I didn't know that,... The Correct Turn
- akcheema: Re: # 182; nb thanks... The Correct Turn
- nb: Cheema, hing is asafoetida... The Correct Turn
- akcheema: Re: # 180 yaar nb... The Correct Turn
- nb: HP, if it was... The Correct Turn
- akcheema: dost_mittar and hamidm sahibaan,... The Correct Turn
- ahmedmadani: When we who write... Politics of PPP and








reply to this interact
write a new interact
add to favorites
flag objectionable content