Bina Shah April 9, 2004
#10 Posted by Saeen on April 11, 2004 12:16:07 pm
Hmm, very poignant, somethings mentioned are what many of us can relate to.
We`re far away from the city, from civilization
But it always feels more human here.
The earth is rich beneath my feet
It carries the seeds that will feed our children
As well as the bones of those that came before us
Lugubrious.
Good work, keep writing.
We`re far away from the city, from civilization
But it always feels more human here.
The earth is rich beneath my feet
It carries the seeds that will feed our children
As well as the bones of those that came before us
Lugubrious.
Good work, keep writing.
#9 Posted by echoboom on April 10, 2004 12:56:36 pm
Bina: I like it
It has roots in your heart as well as the soil. No brainwork here--and that is the greatest achievement (imho) for a poet. When the brain goes on a furlough, without being pushed out, even for a few seconds or minutes Saroush visits and starts dictating. Only then a poem is born.
But when one invokes Saroush, advertisement copies and slogans may result. Some of them really good and original..but never a poem.
Some chowkie ``poets`` do peddle such labels.
Bina please reply if you grasp this:
MiTTee kee muhabbat mein humm aashuftaa sroN neiN
voh QrZ chukaa-eiN haiN , jo vaajib bhee nahee thhay.
Iftikhaar Aarif.
Pohnchee vaheeN pay khaak, jahaaN kaa khameer thhaa.[ meer anees?]
And the best:
Dil sey jo baat nikaltee hai, asar rakhtee hai
pur naheeN; taquat-e prvaaz mgar rakhtee hai
Qudsee-ul-Asl hai raf`at pay nzar rakhtee hai
Khaak say yThhtee hai, grdooN pay guzar rakhtee hai--ALLAMA Iqbal.(who else?)
the beauty of the last two lines is just enchanting..one could never get-over the spell anytime, everytime!
It has roots in your heart as well as the soil. No brainwork here--and that is the greatest achievement (imho) for a poet. When the brain goes on a furlough, without being pushed out, even for a few seconds or minutes Saroush visits and starts dictating. Only then a poem is born.
But when one invokes Saroush, advertisement copies and slogans may result. Some of them really good and original..but never a poem.
Some chowkie ``poets`` do peddle such labels.
Bina please reply if you grasp this:
MiTTee kee muhabbat mein humm aashuftaa sroN neiN
voh QrZ chukaa-eiN haiN , jo vaajib bhee nahee thhay.
Iftikhaar Aarif.
Pohnchee vaheeN pay khaak, jahaaN kaa khameer thhaa.[ meer anees?]
And the best:
Dil sey jo baat nikaltee hai, asar rakhtee hai
pur naheeN; taquat-e prvaaz mgar rakhtee hai
Qudsee-ul-Asl hai raf`at pay nzar rakhtee hai
Khaak say yThhtee hai, grdooN pay guzar rakhtee hai--ALLAMA Iqbal.(who else?)
the beauty of the last two lines is just enchanting..one could never get-over the spell anytime, everytime!
#8 Posted by Warlus on April 10, 2004 11:07:08 am
Bina I sure wish you be writing more articles than poems, but good effort nonetheless.
#7 Posted by rozaiba on April 10, 2004 7:56:23 am
nice bina. reminded me of lyrics from a 90`s rock band:
hai apnay khwaboun kee zameen,
duur kahin, yehaan dil na lagay,
rehtay hain hum bus vahin,
aur kahin dil na lagay...
-Collage
hai apnay khwaboun kee zameen,
duur kahin, yehaan dil na lagay,
rehtay hain hum bus vahin,
aur kahin dil na lagay...
-Collage
#6 Posted by Nadia_Zehra on April 9, 2004 10:34:40 pm
Bina:
`` The land will live longer than its masters
The water will flow long after we have all been washed
away. ``
Timeless truth encapuslating the realities everywhere, very catching... Good Ending...Aching for a Land lover and one who knows beauty and nature of water and roles of God in them...
`` The land will live longer than its masters
The water will flow long after we have all been washed
away. ``
Timeless truth encapuslating the realities everywhere, very catching... Good Ending...Aching for a Land lover and one who knows beauty and nature of water and roles of God in them...
#5 Posted by M.B.Z.Isphahani on April 9, 2004 7:34:20 pm
=== Interact Filtered ===
view this users filtered interacts
view this users filtered interacts
#4 Posted by PunjabiZulu on April 9, 2004 4:22:40 pm
Bina
The first two stanzas reminded me of ``Digging`` by Seamus Heaney. I really liked it. :-)
Is it about Sindh?
I echo what hamidm said. This was an honest and straightforward poem and resonant because of that.
#3 Posted by Godot on April 9, 2004 3:02:09 pm
Bina,
This is way too profound, a wondering, a quest, the meaning of it all...this is Tao...I’m impressed.
I cannot discuss this with you on the internet, in an open forum...but only one on one, face to face...maybe one day...
This is way too profound, a wondering, a quest, the meaning of it all...this is Tao...I’m impressed.
I cannot discuss this with you on the internet, in an open forum...but only one on one, face to face...maybe one day...
#2 Posted by hamidm2 on April 9, 2004 3:02:08 pm
...... just to show that i am not some kind of a reckless rabid iconoclastic poet killer, i will admit that i liked this poem ......... why?..... because it is not contrived............ yup, that`s it ......... most poetry is contrived, pretentious, schmaaltzy, feigned, highfalutin, hollow, pedantic, pompous and phoney - a studied exercise in which the poet sits down to make up stuff that appears to be clever ............ words like ``soiled sand``!......... give me a break!....what is next?..... ``wet water?``..........
.............. bu this was nice ......... simple, easy to read, almost like prose ..........
.............. bu this was nice ......... simple, easy to read, almost like prose ..........
#1 Posted by temporal on April 9, 2004 12:25:20 pm
binoo:
brace yourself!
here comes hamidm...he loves poetry:)
lve,
t
brace yourself!
here comes hamidm...he loves poetry:)
lve,
t
Interact Index
Also by Bina Shah
Similar Articles
- Will Kashmiri Pandits Ever Return to their Abode…? J N Raina
- Doves sameena khan
- An Indian in Pakistan Deepak Sapra
- Standing in the Fields Bina Shah
US Elections 2008 Primaries
Latest Interacts
- masadi: #218 Okhla nice attempt... Terrorism Unveiled
- masadi: nkg you moron, the... The Palestinian Puzzle
- nkg: Re: # 10 VRV... "Now if... Swat Calls For Civil
- nkg: Re: # 10 Zeena... "But, in... The Palestinian Puzzle
- nkg: Re: # 13 masadi... you stupid... The Palestinian Puzzle
- nkg: Re: # 8 Dinaric... "Lert me... The Palestinian Puzzle
- Pew_Research: Re: # 209 Sattar2 That... Terrorism Unveiled
- parthaab: Re: # 8 There is... Swat Calls For Civil








reply to this interact
write a new interact
add to favorites
flag objectionable content