Living Gandhi and King Today: Unbroken Historic Continuity
This is a bad article and everyone here knows it.
Posted by
MantoLives
Oct 4, 2008 12:59 am
An article that ignores Gandhi's racism against black people altogether ...is as one sided as those who only concentrate on that. This is a bad article and everyone here knows it.
Living Gandhi and King Today: Unbroken Historic Continuity
Your logic never makes sense I am afraid. I was never exposed to Pakistani textbooks in my life (though I have examined them recently and found no "hate-gandhi" material in them unfortunately) but I think the fellow was a charlatan and a fraud to the core ...or simply very stupid.
I happened to read a substantial portion of the 90 volumes of Collected Works of Mahatma Gandhi at College and was also exposed to Nirad Chaudhry's "thy hand great anarch" ... Which opened my eyes to Gandhi who I had considered a great leader till about 1999-2000. My enlightenment came at a US university's library. You should try using those things once in a while.
Simply because someone has a different point of view doesn't make them "moron". Your inability to tolerate a point of view thatcounters your deeply held beliefs makes me think that old habits die hard.
And if Harish Hyd is an honest man he will affirm that Sabyasachi Majumdar is indeed a Bengali Indian Hindu. So this "attack the messenger" bullshit might work amongst the mohamadzai tribe of NWFP but in civilized parts of the world it doesn't pass for a good argument.
Go ahead accuse me of being prejudiced blah blah...but facts are sacred.
Posted by
MantoLives
Oct 4, 2008 12:54 am
Adam mian,Your logic never makes sense I am afraid. I was never exposed to Pakistani textbooks in my life (though I have examined them recently and found no "hate-gandhi" material in them unfortunately) but I think the fellow was a charlatan and a fraud to the core ...or simply very stupid.
I happened to read a substantial portion of the 90 volumes of Collected Works of Mahatma Gandhi at College and was also exposed to Nirad Chaudhry's "thy hand great anarch" ... Which opened my eyes to Gandhi who I had considered a great leader till about 1999-2000. My enlightenment came at a US university's library. You should try using those things once in a while.
Simply because someone has a different point of view doesn't make them "moron". Your inability to tolerate a point of view thatcounters your deeply held beliefs makes me think that old habits die hard.
And if Harish Hyd is an honest man he will affirm that Sabyasachi Majumdar is indeed a Bengali Indian Hindu. So this "attack the messenger" bullshit might work amongst the mohamadzai tribe of NWFP but in civilized parts of the world it doesn't pass for a good argument.
Go ahead accuse me of being prejudiced blah blah...but facts are sacred.
Muslims in America
Posted by
MantoLives
Jul 9, 2008 12:07 pm
Yaar truth you are doing such a commendable job presenting the facts... Why stoop to masadi's level?
Muslims in America
Posted by
MantoLives
Jul 9, 2008 11:47 am
Hear not here
Muslims in America
The problem is that you are arguing with a halfwit
He is probably going to say ramswamiramanu who?
On the other hand ibne khuldun is famous for his work in history not science.
Now if only the dimwit knew what rhazes and avicenna actually thought of Islam quran etc he would not be taking pride in their purported achievements.
Now here him speak of his superior wit... I must bow out now.
Posted by
MantoLives
Jul 9, 2008 11:46 am
Truth The problem is that you are arguing with a halfwit
He is probably going to say ramswamiramanu who?
On the other hand ibne khuldun is famous for his work in history not science.
Now if only the dimwit knew what rhazes and avicenna actually thought of Islam quran etc he would not be taking pride in their purported achievements.
Now here him speak of his superior wit... I must bow out now.
Muslims in America
Maybe you should give up this academia business because you suck at it. As they say those who can't do teach and those who can't teach teach gym. Maybe you can join golden gym in faisal town
Posted by
MantoLives
Jul 9, 2008 11:35 am
Aww poor baby ... Are you upset that all these TV stations keep calling me for interviews but a distinguised scholar like you gets ignored?Maybe you should give up this academia business because you suck at it. As they say those who can't do teach and those who can't teach teach gym. Maybe you can join golden gym in faisal town
Muslims in America
The contribution of the
Hindu civilization has been much more substantial than the Arab world in terms of science etc and this is a fact no one can deny.
Posted by
MantoLives
Jul 9, 2008 11:24 am
On this issue of Muslim contributiomlb etc why is it that all leading Muslim scientists were atheists.The contribution of the
Hindu civilization has been much more substantial than the Arab world in terms of science etc and this is a fact no one can deny.
Muslims in America
Posted by
MantoLives
Jul 9, 2008 11:15 am
And may I add what a remarkable insight bj has into his own mind. Just goes to show the couch is not enough ... Chemical therapy is also required in his case.
Muslims in America
I speak every day against discrimination against ahmadis on some TV channel or radio channel right here in Pakistan bringing myself in harm's way despite not being an ahmadi in any real sense.
Thus any discussion I have with you would obviously be useless as you abandoned your flock to the cosy comforts of the west just like your brother from another mother urstruly.
So you see it was necessary and what is more I will choose my battles and ignore you from now on.
Posted by
MantoLives
Jul 9, 2008 11:08 am
And you are right let's not have a useless discussion. I speak every day against discrimination against ahmadis on some TV channel or radio channel right here in Pakistan bringing myself in harm's way despite not being an ahmadi in any real sense.
Thus any discussion I have with you would obviously be useless as you abandoned your flock to the cosy comforts of the west just like your brother from another mother urstruly.
So you see it was necessary and what is more I will choose my battles and ignore you from now on.
Muslims in America
I am simply pointing out the obvious: my irreligiousity has nothing to do with my ahmadi father who was a very religious man in his own right.
I am the best friend you've got ... not bj or others you are leaning on.
Learn to accept the facts. Ahmadis are for all practical purposes as Islamically rigid and conservative as any other Muslim sect.
My father was threatened with a ban by the ahmaddiya community because he had music at my wedding. I rest my case.
Posted by
MantoLives
Jul 9, 2008 10:22 am
Sattar,I am simply pointing out the obvious: my irreligiousity has nothing to do with my ahmadi father who was a very religious man in his own right.
I am the best friend you've got ... not bj or others you are leaning on.
Learn to accept the facts. Ahmadis are for all practical purposes as Islamically rigid and conservative as any other Muslim sect.
My father was threatened with a ban by the ahmaddiya community because he had music at my wedding. I rest my case.
Muslims in America
So this is not about Ahmadis or any other sect or community try as you may. I do not represent Ahmadis and the only link I had with that community was snapped on Dec 10 last.
Ofcourse that doesn't mean I would stop telling the truth about the discrimination that goes on against them...stop me if you can you sobs.
Now go back to giving each other head for which you guys are world famous (on the internet).
Posted by
MantoLives
Jul 2, 2008 07:10 pm
I do not wish to interact with fools here, but since momineen and their Hindu bed fellows are continuously trying to bring in Ahmadis etc into this, let me say this: when it comes to dogma - Ahmadis are nutcases just like wahabis ... Ahmadis also believe that women ought to be covered head to toe in a burqah and that music is haraam. So this is not about Ahmadis or any other sect or community try as you may. I do not represent Ahmadis and the only link I had with that community was snapped on Dec 10 last.
Ofcourse that doesn't mean I would stop telling the truth about the discrimination that goes on against them...stop me if you can you sobs.
Now go back to giving each other head for which you guys are world famous (on the internet).
Restoring the Civil Rights of Ahmadis
Pakistan Zindabad.
Posted by
MantoLives
Jun 17, 2008 05:16 am
Alright losers I am done for the day. This well written article by an enlightened and aware Pakistani is vindication for all the positions I have taken for so many years. More and more patriotic Pakistanis are now ready to reclaim Pakistan to the utter disappointment of freaks on both sides of the border.Pakistan Zindabad.
Restoring the Civil Rights of Ahmadis
Posted by
MantoLives
Jun 17, 2008 05:14 am
whimpering is when you guys invent statements I never made because you can't defend your position.
Restoring the Civil Rights of Ahmadis
"Daiichi bought Ranbaxy so Daiichi is an Indian company now"
Lol. What logic indeed.
Posted by
MantoLives
Jun 17, 2008 05:09 am
"Daiichi bought Ranbaxy so Daiichi is an Indian company now"
Lol. What logic indeed.
Restoring the Civil Rights of Ahmadis
Ofcourse I called Mobilink a Pakistani company... not Orascom. We were talking about the fifteen percent shares of Mobilink going for 540 Million if you recall. So how was I talking about Orascom?
Do you have reading comprehension issues?
Posted by
MantoLives
Jun 17, 2008 05:03 am
Re: # 67Ofcourse I called Mobilink a Pakistani company... not Orascom. We were talking about the fifteen percent shares of Mobilink going for 540 Million if you recall. So how was I talking about Orascom?
Do you have reading comprehension issues?
Restoring the Civil Rights of Ahmadis
Chowk is full of freaks... you, Zeemax, Kharish mian ...
So whats new?
Posted by
MantoLives
Jun 17, 2008 05:01 am
Re: # 61Chowk is full of freaks... you, Zeemax, Kharish mian ...
So whats new?
- MantoLives
- Interacts: 8928
- iLogs: 1034
- Gallery: 0
- Page views: 150673
- Last visitor: guest
- Member since: Jul 25 2003
- Last signin: Oct 14 2009
- Send a message
- Add as friend
- Add to ignore list
- Add to block list


